Toby’s Best Moment: Season Seven, Episode Eleven: Classy Christmas Part 1
When he rubs his neck, indicating to the office that the case he’s on is the Scranton Strangler.
Toby’s Worst Moment: Season Two, Episode Twenty-One: Conflict Resolution
The truth about the “Special Filing Cabinet” in New York. Dwight, and the Dwight v Jim feud may be annoying to deal with, but he wasn’t actually dealing with it and it was terrible as the HR rep and disrespectful to Dwight to not report the issues Dwight was having. Even though it wasn’t legal harassment, Toby still could and should have gotten in trouble for not taking the issue seriously.
Toby’s Best Line: Season Two, Episode Twenty-Two: Casino Night
“Actually I didn’t think it was appropriate to invite children since it’s, uh, you know, there’s gambling and alcohol and it’s in our dangerous warehouse, and, it’s a school night, and you know, hooters is catering, …..is that, is that enough, should I keep going?”
Toby’s Most Memorable Moment: Season Four, Episode Fourteen: Goodbye Toby
Pam gifts Toby a picture of everyone in the office as his going away gift, but because she took the picture. As we know Toby is interested in Pam and while she agrees to take a picture with him neither of them have a camera so he screams “Does anyone have a camera”…..and then later in the episode gets a camera to get pictures taken with Pam