The Case Against Finrod Revisionism 

The case against Finrod revisionism 

I’ve always been frustrated by what I see as bad-faith interpretations of Finrod’s character. You don’t have to like him or find him interesting, but it bothers me when people make claims about him that don’t make sense. When it comes to Finrod, they usually follow a similar pattern, something like: ‘I thought Finrod was good the first time I read the Silmarillion, but now I think he’s bad.’ ‘I thought Finrod was a friend of Men at first, but now I think he actually looked down on the Edain and treated them poorly.’ ‘Finrod comes across as a perfect good guy in the Silmarillion, but what if he’s secretly manipulative and evil?’ That’s what I’m calling Finrod revisionism. This is not a callout post; I’m just giving my reasons why ‘Finrod is actually evil and the Silmarillion is lying to you’ is not a take that does it for me. I think it’s entirely fair to criticize Finrod. He’s not perfect and if he were I think he would be less interesting (more on that later). I just do not vibe with interpretations of his character that paint him as someone who intentionally sacrificed the Edain in battle, someone who committed genocide against the Petty-dwarves, or someone who held prejudiced views, and I think those interpretations are unsupported by canon. This is a long post, so I’ll put it under the cut.

Continua a leggere

More Posts from Penelopes-poppies and Others

4 years ago

Gotta love fics where people just move into the shire and become honorary hobbits. Thorin? Let him reshire. Maglor? Shire. Fuckin Feanor? Put him in the shire. Now I want to see it with Morgoth and Sauron. Depower them and stick them in the shire and watch them become the old married couple of very tall eccentric hobbits

3 years ago

90% of arguments about media could just be solved by saying “different people like different things in their stories” and leaving it at that


Tags
4 years ago

First age family reunions be like:

First Age Family Reunions Be Like:
4 years ago

My BIGGEST pet peeve when it comes to Tolkien is how people will sometimes characterize Melkor’s rebellion as being about him wanting to do his own thing and rebelling against Illuvatar’s oppressive sheet music.

THERE WAS NO SHEET MUSIC!  Illuvatar wasn’t forcing anything.  The Ainulindale was improv.  Illuvatar just gave them the theme, the idea, the feeling, the starting point.  The Ainur were drawing inspiration from the thought of Illuvatar, sure, and so long as they were in harmony the music played precisely as Illuvatar intended because Illuvatar had created them and knew how they worked together.  But the music of the Ainur before Melkor’s dissonance was quintessentially creative, as well as corroborative.  It was spontaneous, perfect harmony of free individuals perfectly in tune with each other, whose improvisations were constantly building upon each other.

Melkor’s rebellion was not about asserting his freedom of expression, because his expression was already free.  Instead it was explicitly about making his own voice louder and more important than anyone else’s, and subjugating the creativity of others to instead convince or force them to follow him exactly in repetitive unison.  And so, when Melkor’s goal became drown everyone else out, instead of make beautiful music together, his music became less creative, less innovative, and less his.

So it kind of annoys me when people talk about Melkor like he’s all for freedom of expression when he’s pretty much the opposite of that.

4 years ago

I try not to post about real life serious stuff, but there’s been a lot of… unfortunate essays written about how it is Zuko’s duty to help Azula because Iroh helped him.

I don’t know who needs to hear this, but it is never your ‘duty’ to stick around and help someone through person through their mental illness. That is redoubled when they are abusive or put you in physical danger.

I think most people realize that cartoons do not equal real life and liberties can and SHOULD be taken for fiction, but this trope seems to be gaining traction so I gotta put it out there. When the cabin pressure drops and someone you love is going through a mental breakdown, make sure you put the oxygen mask over your own face first before you help them with theirs. If you know what I mean.

3 years ago

are you considering getting into NFTs but are on the fence due to environmental concerns or fear of being labelled a "complete douchebag"?

do you want to enjoy owning a unique piece of artwork while still enjoying the possibility of one day getting a girlfriend?

then boy, do I have the option for you!

did you know that there are THOUSANDS of artists on THIS VERY WEBSITE and many others who will make you your very own piece of artwork for the same price or less than an NFT?

these gorgeous artworks are called "commissions", and are environmentally friendly AND don't look like pure shit!

if that wasn't enough, many lovely artists on the internet will, for a price, PHYSICALLY MAKE AN ARTWORK IN REAL LIFE AND MAIL IT TO YOUR OWN HOME! That's right, a PHYSICAL OBJECT that is completely unique and made just for you!

Benefits of Commissions:

Environmentally Friendly!

Supports Real, Hardworking Artists!

Actual Real Art That Looks Good!

Not A Literal Scam!

I Will Stop Fucking Your Mom!

"OP," I hear you cry, "how do I get my grubby hands on such a deal??"

don't fret, dear reader! simply check the bio or pinned post of any artist on any site for further directions! Many will have a "commissions open" or "commissions closed" sign, and often you will find a post with prices or instructions on how to contact the artist for details!

"What if I can't afford it?" you say? Well, you can also support the artist by REBLOGGING their artwork! (NEVER repost without permission, I'll kill you)

stop buying NFTs and support real artists!

2 years ago

You know those edits that are like "(fandom) + Greek words for love" usually being Eros, Ludus, Storge, Mania, Pragma, Philia and Agape?

Why oh why has no one done an edit that is like "Sons of Feanor + completely fucked up ideas about love"? I feel like this could be done


Tags
3 years ago

Currently thinking about a Maglor Requiem: the kyrie is a seven-voice fugue


Tags
3 years ago
Hyphens, En Dashes And Em Dashes

Hyphens, en Dashes and em Dashes

Oh- and let’s not forget the minus sign, that thing on your keyboard that can be misused as any one of the above! 

It took me a long time to understand the differences. 

The minus sign                         (-)

The hyphen                               (-)

The en dash                              (–)

The em dash                            (—)

Visually, not much in it, is there?  

But oh what a difference the length makes! 

The minus sign is a mathematical symbol. That’s it. Don’t misuse it for anything else.

The hyphen is used to join two elements to form a compound word, like  self-restraint. Numbers between twenty-one and ninety-nine should also be hyphenated when they’re spelled out. Sherlock Holmes-Watson or John Watson-Holmes (interesting to know which one wins in the battle). You should also use a hyphen in a compound modifier before a noun, as in The Crossed Keys Inn was a dog-friendly pub.

The shorter en dash  is used when describing ranges and with the meaning “to” in phrases like “Dover–Calais crossing.” It applies to ranges of numbers, such as times, page numbers, or scores (I’ll schedule you from 4:30–5:00). That said, outside of formally printed documents, it is increasingly being replaced with a hyphen, so if you miss this one, Sherlock won’t hang you for it. 

The longer em dash (—) is about as wide as the letter M (duh, now I get why it’s called this). It’s used to separate extra information or mark a break in a sentence.  An em dash is most often used to indicate a pause in a sentence. It’s stronger than a comma, but weaker than a period or semicolon. 

You can use a pair of em dashes to draw special attention to parenthetical information, as in

Sherlock—who was wearing the same purple shirt of sex—entered the room carrying his violin..

You can use a single em dash to add explanatory or amplifying information, especially when the information is surprising:

I opened the door and there she stood—Eurus, my long lost sister.

Em dashes can also signal a sudden interruption, particularly in dialogue:

“Wait! I forgot to tell you—” The door slammed shut between us and I missed whatever John was trying to say.

Interestingly, there is no firm rule about spaces around the em dash (either word—word or word — word). It’s a matter of style. Whichever style you choose, use it consistently throughout your document.

The em dash is a relatively artistic punctuation mark, compared to the more technical hyphen and en dash, both of which need to be used accurately in legal contracts, for example. 

Hyphens, En Dashes And Em Dashes

Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • maenefa
    maenefa reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • petit-cactus
    petit-cactus liked this · 5 months ago
  • serene-faerie
    serene-faerie liked this · 10 months ago
  • unfortunatelyuncreative
    unfortunatelyuncreative reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • readalong
    readalong liked this · 1 year ago
  • estel-and-agape
    estel-and-agape liked this · 1 year ago
  • the-old-fashioned-girl
    the-old-fashioned-girl reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • yuan1819
    yuan1819 liked this · 1 year ago
  • rainbowfractals
    rainbowfractals liked this · 1 year ago
  • the-old-fashioned-girl
    the-old-fashioned-girl liked this · 1 year ago
  • general-illyrin
    general-illyrin liked this · 2 years ago
  • 638287492818472
    638287492818472 liked this · 2 years ago
  • dykedaji
    dykedaji reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • glitteringaglarond
    glitteringaglarond reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • anipologist
    anipologist liked this · 2 years ago
  • truevanhelsing
    truevanhelsing liked this · 2 years ago
  • pendularium
    pendularium liked this · 2 years ago
  • toreadorkable
    toreadorkable liked this · 2 years ago
  • auroramama
    auroramama liked this · 2 years ago
  • soundsofmiddlearth
    soundsofmiddlearth liked this · 2 years ago
  • assamteawithbooks
    assamteawithbooks liked this · 2 years ago
  • energence2
    energence2 liked this · 3 years ago
  • cyraniadebergerac
    cyraniadebergerac reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • cyraniadebergerac
    cyraniadebergerac liked this · 3 years ago
  • haniju
    haniju liked this · 3 years ago
  • aratafinwe
    aratafinwe reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • aratafinwe
    aratafinwe liked this · 3 years ago
  • pachelbelsheadcanon
    pachelbelsheadcanon liked this · 3 years ago
  • cuarthol
    cuarthol liked this · 3 years ago
  • miriel-therindes
    miriel-therindes liked this · 3 years ago
  • crownlessliestheking
    crownlessliestheking reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • shrimp-paste
    shrimp-paste liked this · 3 years ago
  • rusalyetella129
    rusalyetella129 liked this · 3 years ago
  • toastyteakettle
    toastyteakettle reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • neverfadinglands
    neverfadinglands liked this · 3 years ago
  • curiousbluepencil
    curiousbluepencil reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • curiousbluepencil
    curiousbluepencil liked this · 3 years ago
  • xonference
    xonference reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • gaycodedvillainy
    gaycodedvillainy liked this · 3 years ago
  • queeninthenorth283
    queeninthenorth283 liked this · 3 years ago
  • vilewile
    vilewile liked this · 3 years ago
penelopes-poppies - lots of Tolkien and autism, no actual poppies
lots of Tolkien and autism, no actual poppies

she/her, cluttering is my fluency disorder and the state of my living space, God gave me Pathological Demand Avoidance because They knew I'd be too powerful without it, of the opinion that "y'all" should be accepted in formal speech, 18+ [ID: profile pic is a small brown snail climbing up a bright green shallot, surrounded by other shallot stalks. End ID.]

293 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags