All Art Is Derivative. Yes, There Should Be Protections Of The Rights Of Artists That Their Work Can't

All art is derivative. Yes, there should be protections of the rights of artists that their work can't be used in databases of AI art without consent. And yes AI does not consciously create art. In that sense, it is a tool for creating art. I don't see why these things make AI art inherently wrong or anyone using them wrong. By the way, I have only ever shared AI art with a small number of friends and only from programs I trust to be using public domain datasets You shouldn't paint everyone using AI for art with the same brush.

AI Art and Why It Can Go Die In A Fire

Why am I opposed to Stable Diffusion and AI Art in its current incarnation:

Some people seem to believe AI can “learn” art. Like it learns the concepts of perspective, value, anatomy, colour etc. through images and then recreates art based on this knowledge.

This is a misconception.

An AI doesn’t “know” things. It has no concept for artistic fundamentals. It just learns associations based on the data it’s given in a way that’s completely , vastly different to the way a human brain does. An AI can only recreate based on known image data. Those recreations can be blended in a very complex way, but they will ALWAYS be derived directly from image data it’s trained on.

A human can take a paint-bucket, and throw it at a canvas, and then mush paint around with their fingers. An AI can’t do that;  it can only blend image data that best fits “canvas with messy splashed paint”. It will pull from all the image data it’s categorized with “canvas”, “splash”, “paint”, etc. and then blend them by placing datapoints next to other datapoints that it has “learned” will most suitably go next to each other.

Human learning creates complex conceptual structures. Our concept of an “apple” may contain many elements such as the colour red, how heavy it is, its overall form, how you hold it, and what it tastes like. An AI’s concept of an “apple” is whatever images it associates with the word “apple” based on text cues in its training.

When you tell it to paint “a hand holding an apple”, it will recreate and blend many images of hands with many images of apples in a way that best fit each other depending on weights defined by the data its analyzed.

Any presumption that AI can “learn” art theory and then make art through its knowledge of this is incorrect, and would require a level of general AI intelligence we are nowhere near capable of building yet, and we won’t with our current models because they are not creating actual epistemology, merely datapoint-based imitation without actual integration or understanding.

But the bottom line? All AI art is derivative and, unless it was trained exclusively on works in the public domain, there is definitely a case to argue that the companies creating these algorithms are violating the copyright of the artists whose works they are using without there first being a contract, agreement, or royalties (which is the thing these companies are trying to weasel out of by creating these AIs in the first place.) There is a reason why Clip Studio Paint, the latest of money-chasers jumping aboard the Stable Diffusion pony, issued out a warning that states, verbatim, “we cannot guarantee that images generated by the current model will not infringe on the rights of others.“

They know. They just don’t care- and everyone who ‘creates’ AI art is a willing participant in the infringing of copyright of millions of artists who never gave consent to have their works used in this fashion.

More Posts from Enbylvania65000 and Others

2 years ago
Regardless Of What You Think Of This Tree… This Comment Was My Favourite Out Of The Collection Of People
Regardless Of What You Think Of This Tree… This Comment Was My Favourite Out Of The Collection Of People
Regardless Of What You Think Of This Tree… This Comment Was My Favourite Out Of The Collection Of People

Regardless of what you think of this tree… this comment was my favourite out of the collection of people who didn’t know deer shed their antlers every spring

2 years ago

My old person trait is that I think a website should work in a web browser and not try to open an app


Tags
4 years ago
I Don’t Have Anything Grand For The 13th Anniversary, But Here’s A Drawing I Got Done Of My Favourite

i don’t have anything grand for the 13th anniversary, but here’s a drawing i got done of my favourite bot earlier. happy anniversary spg!! 💘

don’t trace, copy, or steal.

4 years ago

My niece enjoys reading but she struggles with pronunciations of words that don't sound how they're spelt. It doesn't stop her from enjoying reading and wanting to do it, though. Her learning difficulties make it hard for her but she does it because she enjoys it.

We all struggle through life trying to do things we either enjoy or don't.

For neurotypical people, it's not a question of whether or not they can do they things they don't enjoy but a matter of just doing it because it has to be done.

That's not the case for neurodiverse people.

For adhd and autism, it's very dependent on how engaging the things are and how they relate to any interests an autistic or adhd person has.

For depression, it's very dependent on being necessary and treated like it's either the Most Important Thing Ever To Do, or something that is just another motion to perform. There may be no joy in it, but if it's performed then it's over and done with.

For learning difficulties and disabilities, it's very dependent on how things are described, how complex they are, and what the end result Has To Be.

In all these cases, there's always an issue with the question of Can. The issue is that it doesn't matter how much a neurodiverse person may Want or Need to do something, whether or not it's something they enjoy/find unpleasant, it's almost physically Impossible to do the thing because the Brain Refuses To Cooperate.

Imagine you're standing in front of an electric fence. You try to put your hand on it. Your brain will literally stop you from doing so. In almost every case, you cannot touch that electric fence. You might manage it if you psych yourself up and try real hard, but that still isn't a guarantee.

In most cases, you won't manage to touch that fence. Your hand will freeze close to it, maybe even close enough to feel the electricity humming in the fence. But that last distance won't be closed.

You simply cannot do it.

That's what it is like to have a neurodiverse mind sometimes. That's what it's like to be neurodiverse.

You want to touch the fence because it's something you Have To Do, but your brain is saying No, No Thanks, We're Not Doing That and you end up stuck.

And the people who can touch the fence look at you standing there, unable to touch it, and judge you because "look, I'm touching the fence because it's my job and I gotta do it, I don't enjoy it but it's what I need to do, why are you being so lazy".

Sometimes, sometimes my niece just Can't Do The Work she's assigned from school during this period of lockdown and more home schooling. She tries but her brain is physically refusing to let her.

So she gets upset. She gets frustrated. She cries. She tries to avoid answering. She'll say the wrong answer because all she cares about is just giving an answer at this point and Moving On.

It's easy to get frustrated back. It's easy to get mean. It's easy to not understand because I'm not her.

But she's trying and she might be failing at the work but she's trying and trying hard. It's hurting her to try so hard because she's fighting against her own brain with her mind. That's Hard.

Being neurodiverse is a constant battle with your own brain and body, neuroses and anxieties. It's so easy to be cruel and judging when you're not the one on the front line.

It's so easy to call others lazy because you don't see and don't understand the mountain they've had to climb without equipment just to reach the same starting line as you just strolled up to.

My niece is trying. She's always trying.

Her reading will improve with time and encouragement.

It will never improve with judgement and cruelty in the guise of motivation.

To be neurodiverse is to be in a war without end; there are only brief periods of rest spent around campfires with others in the same war and occasional civilians who judge the time spent around campfires just resting to be a "waste of time" and "lazy".

This is what it is to be neurodiverse. This is what it is to be autistic, adhd, depressed, learning disabled, and so on. This is what it is to be Abnormal. And that's okay.

The world and people may say and imply otherwise. But there's nothing wrong with trying to do something and finding your brain won't let you. Brains just be like that, sometimes.


Tags
2 years ago
Cadmium Red 🔥 All Oil On Wood Panel, By Me, 2022
Cadmium Red 🔥 All Oil On Wood Panel, By Me, 2022
Cadmium Red 🔥 All Oil On Wood Panel, By Me, 2022
Cadmium Red 🔥 All Oil On Wood Panel, By Me, 2022

cadmium red 🔥 all oil on wood panel, by me, 2022


Tags
art
2 years ago
Technically True.

Technically true.

2 years ago
Nēnē (Branta Sandvicensis)

Nēnē (Branta sandvicensis)

© Melanie Barnett


Tags
4 years ago
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)
Castles - Art By Alan Lee (1984)

Castles - art by Alan Lee (1984)

4 years ago

If you’re reading this please be nice to yourself today because you do matter

4 years ago

It’s my favorite thing when a lesbian is just like “I got extra fries with my meal, gay rights” or an enby is like “wow trans rights I just got a free gift card to the movies” or a bi dude is like “finally found a plant that won’t die, queer rights I guess.” Like that is the funniest shit I don’t care.

Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • draw-resource-repo
    draw-resource-repo reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • bluehoodedhuntress
    bluehoodedhuntress liked this · 2 years ago
  • haniieo
    haniieo liked this · 2 years ago
  • abigrock
    abigrock reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • missedthestartgun
    missedthestartgun liked this · 2 years ago
  • j33zits
    j33zits liked this · 2 years ago
  • j33zits
    j33zits reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • the-killing-moon
    the-killing-moon reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • hydethesturdy
    hydethesturdy liked this · 2 years ago
  • moonbandit
    moonbandit reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • l4v3nd3rsblog
    l4v3nd3rsblog liked this · 2 years ago
  • boymagicalgirl
    boymagicalgirl liked this · 2 years ago
  • thecrusaderchronicles
    thecrusaderchronicles liked this · 2 years ago
  • seriously-mike
    seriously-mike liked this · 2 years ago
  • vorpalmeow
    vorpalmeow reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • solid-snake-plissken
    solid-snake-plissken reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • bob-soup
    bob-soup reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • bob-soup
    bob-soup liked this · 2 years ago
  • dreamsverge
    dreamsverge liked this · 2 years ago
  • bunniculoid
    bunniculoid liked this · 2 years ago
  • diegiszekely
    diegiszekely liked this · 2 years ago
  • thyroyalclowness
    thyroyalclowness liked this · 2 years ago
  • vegas-syntaxis
    vegas-syntaxis liked this · 2 years ago
  • vegas-syntaxis
    vegas-syntaxis reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • each-uisge-enthusiast
    each-uisge-enthusiast liked this · 2 years ago
  • yris-latteyi
    yris-latteyi liked this · 2 years ago
  • sonolus
    sonolus liked this · 2 years ago
  • artclaudiaalick
    artclaudiaalick liked this · 2 years ago
  • lyndsefinethequeen
    lyndsefinethequeen reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • lyndsefinethequeen
    lyndsefinethequeen liked this · 2 years ago
  • thatrudeamerican
    thatrudeamerican liked this · 2 years ago
  • kyoslittleflame
    kyoslittleflame liked this · 2 years ago
  • akitalockwood
    akitalockwood liked this · 2 years ago
  • 1minnim
    1minnim reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • thereisabunni
    thereisabunni reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • thereisabunni
    thereisabunni liked this · 2 years ago
  • the-great-squidini
    the-great-squidini liked this · 2 years ago
  • emeraldfire-fandoms
    emeraldfire-fandoms liked this · 2 years ago
  • just-1-scorpio
    just-1-scorpio liked this · 2 years ago
  • enbylvania65000
    enbylvania65000 reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • vorpalmeow
    vorpalmeow reblogged this · 2 years ago
enbylvania65000 - Enbylvania 6-5000
Enbylvania 6-5000

queer, hiloni, conlanger; pronouns: they/she/he

240 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags