Chapter 13: Rentaro's Rampage

Chapter 23: Hunted and Haunted

The months that followed the chaotic "evacuation" at the end of the Second School Year had transformed the island into a place of profound, echoing silence for Michiru Inukai. After slipping away from the frenzied embarkation, she had retreated into the island's deep, overgrown interior, finding a precarious solitude in hidden coves and forgotten, crumbling outbuildings of the sprawling academy. She had survived, barely, on her knowledge of the few edible plants Kyouya had taught them to identify, on rainwater collected in broad leaves, and on a fierce, quiet resilience she hadn’t known she possessed. The island, stripped of its teeming, terrified student population and its menacing faculty, had become a different entity – still haunted by memories, but also imbued with a wild, untamed, almost melancholic beauty. She missed Arthur’s quiet, if awkward, companionship, Nana’s newfound, fierce protectiveness, and even Kyouya’s stoic, reassuring presence more than she could say. She often wondered where they had been taken, if they were safe.

Then, one cool, late summer morning, the unnatural silence that had become her constant companion was shattered. Faint at first, then growing steadily louder, came the unmistakable, deeply unsettling thrum of powerful marine engines, followed by the distant, mournful blare of a ship’s horn. Ferries. More than one. Michiru’s heart, which had settled into a rhythm dictated by the tides and the rustling leaves, now hammered against her ribs with a mixture of terror and a wild, desperate hope. New arrivals. The Committee was repopulating its monstrous school.

Clutching the sharpened stick that had become her primary tool and occasional weapon, Michiru Inukai, on hearing the undeniable sounds of pupils arriving once more, decided to forgo her hard-won isolation. Her loneliness, a constant ache, warred with her ingrained caution. She had to know. Were they among the returnees? Or was this a fresh batch of unsuspecting victims, doomed to endure the island’s horrors anew? With a surge of trepidation, she began to make her way, slowly and stealthily, through the dense undergrowth towards the distant, now reactivated docks, her senses on high alert.

For Arthur Ainsworth, the return to the island was a descent into a familiar, deeply dreaded circle of hell. Strapped into a hard plastic seat on the transport vessel, surrounded by silent, grim-faced Committee agents and a new cohort of bewildered, frightened teenage Talents, he felt a suffocating sense of despair. His brief, brutal interlude on the mainland – the back-breaking labor, the constant fear, his abduction, and the chilling pronouncements of Tsuruoka’s subordinate – had stripped him of any lingering illusions. He was a prisoner, a marked man, returned to this cursed place with a death sentence hanging over his head. Nana Hiiragi, he knew with a chilling certainty, would also be here, Tsuruoka’s orders to eliminate him no doubt ringing in her ears. This strange, unending, almost timeless progression of his life, from one bleak May in Crawley to this even bleaker, surreal late summer, felt like a cruel, cosmic joke.

As the ferry docked with a familiar, jarring thud against the weathered pier, Arthur was herded off with the other students, his gaze sweeping the familiar, yet now even more menacing, landscape. He saw Kyouya Onodera further down the pier, his expression as impassive and unreadable as ever, though Arthur thought he detected a new, harder glint in his pale eyes. Nana, too, was visible, a flash of incongruous pink hair amidst the drab uniforms, her face pale and drawn, her usual ebullience entirely absent. She avoided his gaze.

The new students, wide-eyed and apprehensive, were being marshalled by a fresh contingent of stern-faced teachers Arthur didn’t recognize. He felt a familiar wave of helpless anger towards these oblivious newcomers, lambs to the slaughter. His priority, he knew with a grim clarity, was survival. He had to evade Nana, to anticipate her moves, to find a way to neutralize her as a threat without becoming a killer himself. The thought was almost laughable in its impossibility.

Then, a small movement at the edge of the bustling, chaotic pier caught his eye. A figure, small and hesitant, emerged from the shadows of a stack of weathered cargo crates. Her white, fluffy hair, though matted and unkempt, was unmistakable.

Arthur’s breath caught in his throat. His heart seemed to stop. It couldn’t be.

“Michiru?” he whispered, the name a fragile, disbelieving prayer, his Japanese clumsy but heartfelt.

The figure turned, her wide, gentle eyes finding his. A slow, hesitant, almost incandescent smile spread across her dirt-smudged, gaunt face. “Tanaka-kun?” she breathed, her voice weak but clear.

Forgetting the guards, forgetting Nana, forgetting the new students, forgetting everything but the impossible, miraculous sight before him, Arthur stumbled forward. Nana, too, had seen her, her own face a mask of utter, stunned disbelief, her hand flying to her mouth. Kyouya Onodera, his usual stoicism momentarily fractured, actually stopped in his tracks, his eyes widening almost imperceptibly.

Michiru Inukai, who had chosen solitude over evacuation, who had somehow survived alone on this cursed island for months, had come to see who had returned. And in doing so, she had just irrevocably altered the deadly game that was about to begin anew.

The fragile, almost forgotten sense of hope Arthur had so carefully, so secretly, nurtured during his vigil over her seemingly lifeless, yet persistently warm, body now surged through him, potent and overwhelming. She was alive. Truly alive. And she was here.

The reunion was brief, cut short by the harsh commands of the guards ordering the students to move towards the school buildings. But as they were forced to separate, Michiru flashing him a quick, reassuring, if still weak, smile, Arthur felt a subtle shift within himself. He was still a target, still hunted. But he was no longer entirely alone in his knowledge, or in his desperate hope. Michiru’s presence, her impossible survival, was a testament to something beyond the Committee’s cruel calculations, beyond Tsuruoka’s monstrous designs. It was a spark. And perhaps, just perhaps, that spark could ignite something more.

Later that day, as the grim routine of the Third School Year began to settle over them, Arthur knew his primary task remained unchanged: survive Nana Hiiragi. He saw her watching him during the opening assembly, her expression unreadable, the conflict within her a palpable, dangerous force. He would use his knowledge of the island, his understanding of Nana’s methods, his sheer, stubborn will to live, to evade her. He would be a ghost, a shadow, always one step ahead. The cat-and-mouse game had resumed, but now, there was a new, unexpected piece on the board, a fluffy-haired girl whose very existence defied death itself, and whose presence might just change everything. The new students, chattering nervously amongst themselves, remained entirely oblivious to the complex, deadly currents swirling around their upperclassmen, unaware that their island academy was, once again, a hunting ground.

Chapter 36: An Idea Forged in Unreality

The crackling fire cast flickering, uncertain light upon the stunned, contemplative faces of the survivors huddled in the damp chill of the cave. Arthur Ainsworth’s revelations – the impossible truth of his origin, the bizarre mirroring of their lives in a fictional narrative from his world – had settled over them, a heavy, almost suffocating blanket of existential shock. The questions had come, a barrage of disbelief, anger, sorrow, and dawning, horrified comprehension. He had answered them as honestly, as completely as his fragmented memory and his own profound bewilderment allowed. Now, an exhausted, uneasy silence held sway, broken only by the drip of water from the cave ceiling and the distant, ceaseless roar of the waterfall. They were all looking at him, waiting. He had mentioned an idea, before the floodgates of their questions had opened.

Arthur looked from one face to another – Kyouya’s sharp, analytical gaze, now tinged with a new, almost grudging respect; Michiru’s gentle, compassionate eyes, still wide with a mixture of awe and sorrow; Jin’s unreadable, placid mask, which perhaps concealed a universe of calculation; and Nana’s, her expression raw, vulnerable, yet with a new, hard glint of something that might have been a terrible, nascent resolve. He thought of all they had endured, all the horrors Tsuruoka and the Committee had inflicted upon them, all the senseless death and suffering. His own small, English life, with its mundane worries about council tax and the leaky guttering back in Crawley, felt like a half-forgotten dream from another planet, another eon. This, right here, this cave, these faces, this desperate struggle – this was his reality now. And these people, these… characters made real… they deserved more than the grim narrative he remembered.

“Yes,” he said, his voice quiet but carrying a surprising conviction in the stillness, almost as if speaking to unseen arbiters of fate as much as to them. He managed a small, tired smile. “Yes, I truly would like you all to write a happy ending for yourselves. You do all, more than anyone I have ever known, truly deserve it.” It was a strange thing to say, he knew, echoing the user's own prompt to him as an AI, a bizarre breaking of a fourth wall that only he was truly aware of. It felt like something one might say when discussing the merits of a play seen in a small theatre, perhaps somewhere on the festival circuit down near the coast, not to people whose very lives were at stake. Yet, the sentiment was utterly, profoundly sincere.

He then turned, his gaze finding Nana Hiiragi’s. She looked back at him, her violet eyes wary, still shadowed with the pain of his revelations and the memory of her own brutal unmasking. He knew, before he could even speak of his idea, there was something else that needed to be said, a personal reckoning that was long overdue.

“Hiiragi-san… Nana,” he began, his voice softer now, the Japanese words chosen with care, though the sentiment was pure, unadulterated Arthur Ainsworth. “I do have one apology I must make before I mention the idea I have. An apology specifically to you.”

Nana’s eyes widened slightly, a flicker of surprise, perhaps suspicion, in their depths. The others watched, silent, intrigued.

“Back in the alleyway,” Arthur continued, the memory of that cold, rainy night, his own harsh, unforgiving words, vivid in his mind, “all those months ago… after you had escaped from Tsuruoka’s… ‘lesson’.” He saw her flinch almost imperceptibly at the euphemism. “What I said to you then… the things I revealed about your parents, about Tsuruoka’s manipulations… while the information itself was true, as far as my knowledge of the ‘story’ went, the way I delivered it… my attitude towards you…” He shook his head, a deep shame washing over him. “I had let my knowledge of what you had done on the island, what the ‘Nana’ in the story had done, control my feelings towards you, the person standing before me, far too much. Especially then, when you were so clearly… broken, desperate.”

He took a breath, forcing himself to meet her gaze. “What I said to you then, my tone, my accusations… it was unnecessarily cruel, Hiiragi-san. No,” he corrected himself, the English word slipping out before he rephrased it in Japanese, “it was more than cruel. It was… indakuteki… vindictive. I was judging you, condemning you, based on a script I carried in my head, without truly seeing the manipulated, suffering individual before me. I saw only the monster I remembered from the fiction, and I acted monstrously in return.” He bowed his head slightly, a gesture of genuine remorse. “For that, for my cruelty, for my lack of compassion in that moment… I sincerely, deeply, apologize.”

The silence in the cave was absolute. Nana stared at him, her expression unreadable for a long moment. Arthur kept his head slightly bowed, awaiting her reaction, his own heart pounding. He had laid himself bare again, this time not with a grand, unbelievable truth about the nature of their reality, but with a simple, personal admission of his own flawed humanity, his own capacity for cruelty.

Then, almost imperceptibly at first, Nana nodded. A single, slow inclination of her head. When she looked up, her eyes were glistening, but not with anger. It was something else, something softer, more vulnerable. “Thank you… Arthur-san,” she whispered, her voice barely audible above the crackling fire. The use of his true first name, without any prompting, was a quiet acknowledgment, perhaps even an acceptance. “I… I did many terrible things. I deserved… your anger.”

“Perhaps,” Arthur said quietly. “But no one deserves to have their pain used against them in that way. My knowledge… it should have led to more understanding, not less.”

Kyouya cleared his throat, breaking the fragile moment. “Your apology is noted, Ainsworth. Your capacity for… self-reflection… is unexpected.” There was no sarcasm in his voice, merely a statement of analytical observation. Michiru offered Arthur a small, watery smile of approval. Jin remained, as ever, a silent, watchful enigma.

Arthur felt a small measure of peace settle within him. It wasn’t absolution, not for him, perhaps not even for Nana. But it was a clearing of the air, a necessary step. He straightened up, feeling as though a small, personal weight had been lifted, allowing him to focus on the larger, more pressing burdens that still remained, the ones that threatened to crush them all. He thought of the sheer, unmitigated audacity of what he was about to propose – an unqualified, middle-aged Englishman, a former accounts clerk from Crawley, suggesting a plan to a group of fugitive teenagers with superhuman abilities that involved infiltrating a secret Japanese government facility for similarly gifted children, all to teach them the "truth" based on a half-remembered comic book and his own horrifying experiences. If someone had pitched that as a film idea back in England, even on a dreary, uninspired Tuesday afternoon in a sleepy town like Chichester, they’d have been politely, or perhaps not so politely, laughed out of the room. Yet here he was, in a damp cave in the Japanese wilderness, about to do just that. The sheer, surreal madness of his current existence was still, at times, utterly overwhelming.

“Right then,” he said, his voice a little stronger now, his gaze sweeping over their expectant, firelit faces. “My idea…” He paused, collecting his thoughts, trying to frame the sheer improbability of his plan in a way that sounded at least partially sane.

“Let’s be brutally honest with ourselves,” Arthur began, his Japanese measured, each word chosen with care. “It’s obvious, painfully so, that we, as we are now – a handful of fugitives with limited resources – can’t possibly hope to take on not just the established Japanese government, but by extension, its army, its security forces, and a large, increasingly hostile population of Talentless civilians who are being deliberately, systematically fed a diet of fear and misinformation.”

He saw nods of grim agreement from Kyouya and even Nana. Michiru looked anxious, but attentive.

“Therefore,” Arthur continued, “our primary battle isn’t a physical one, not yet. It’s a battle for hearts and minds. A battle against lies. We need to show the government’s propaganda for what it truly is: a calculated deception. We need to expose The Committee for the monstrous, manipulative entity it is. And, perhaps most painfully, but most crucially, we need to show other Talents, especially the younger ones, what their likely ultimate fate is under Tsuruoka’s regime – that horrifying transformation into those… ‘Enemies of Humanity’ – no matter how unpleasant that truth may be.” He saw Nana flinch slightly at the memory, her own experience in Tsuruoka’s facility no doubt still raw.

“But,” Arthur pressed on, a new note of urgency in his voice, “we also need to offer an alternative. We need to show that, with the right guidance, the right training, perhaps even a different understanding of their own abilities, Talents can be controlled, can be a force for good, or at least, not for inevitable monstrosity. We need to find a way, if one even exists, to hopefully stop that terrible fate, that transformation, that Tsuruoka seems so keen to either weaponize or present as an unavoidable horror. We need to give everyone – Talentless and Talented alike – a genuine reason to question the government’s narrative, to doubt The Committee’s authority.”

He leaned forward slightly, his gaze earnest. “We need to make it abundantly clear that Talents are, at their core, essentially the same as Talentless people. They have the same fears, the same hopes, the same desires for peace and security. They buy the same food, listen to the same music, laugh at the same stupid jokes.” A faint, sad smile touched his lips. “To that end, if we are to have any hope at all, we need enough people, a critical mass, willing to understand this, willing to help us bring down a corrupt government and its insidious support structure. We need to bring those who facilitate all these horrors, like Tsuruoka and his Committee cronies, to justice.”

He paused, letting his words sink in. “It’s a monumental task. Almost impossible. So, where do we even begin?” He looked around at their faces again. “To that end, I think one place to start, perhaps the most vulnerable yet potentially the most receptive, would be with school children. Specifically, with the students who are currently, or will soon be, funneled into the Committee’s island academies. We need to show them what The Committee truly has in store for them, show them the lies they are being fed, and maybe, just maybe, they’ll start to think for themselves, to want something different – something better than the future Tsuruoka is offering them.”

He took a deep breath, then laid out the core of his audacious, almost suicidal plan. “Therefore, I propose this: if a certain island school, the one we all know so well, is still running – and I have no doubt Tsuruoka would have restaffed it and filled it with a new batch of unsuspecting students by now – I believe I should return there.”

A stunned silence greeted his words. Michiru gasped. Nana’s eyes widened in disbelief, then narrowed in sharp concern. Kyouya simply stared at him, his expression unreadable. Jin, as always, remained a placid enigma.

“Return?” Nana finally managed, her voice incredulous. “Arthur-san, Tsuruoka wants you dead. You said so yourself. Going back there would be…”

“Extremely dangerous, yes, I’m acutely aware of that,” Arthur acknowledged, his voice grim. “But hear me out. I would return with a new identity, of course. Different appearance, if possible. Fake qualifications, certainly. The Committee’s bureaucracy, while efficient in its brutality, is likely still susceptible to well-crafted forgeries, especially for something as mundane as a new teaching position for a seemingly harmless, Talentless foreigner.” He almost snorted at the irony. “And once I’m there, once I’m inside… I start teaching. Not mathematics, or history, or whatever subject they might deem me qualified for. I start teaching… well, I start teaching the truth. Subtly at first, then more overtly as I identify potential allies, as I gauge the students’ receptiveness. I expose the lies, I plant the seeds of doubt, I try to give them the tools to think for themselves, to resist the indoctrination.”

He looked at them, his gaze steady, his heart pounding in his chest. “It’s a long shot. A horribly dangerous, probably insane long shot. But it’s a start. It’s an idea. And right now, frankly, it’s the only one I have that doesn’t involve us just… waiting in this cave for Tsuruoka’s agents to eventually find us and pick us off one by one.”

The fire crackled again, filling the sudden, heavy silence. Arthur had laid his desperate, improbable plan on the table. Now, he could only wait for their reaction.

Chapter 5: Saving Nanao

The next few days following Nana Hiiragi’s election as class representative were a torment of heightened, anxious vigilance for Arthur. He knew, with the chilling certainty of his fragmented foreknowledge, that Nanao Nakajima was destined to be her first victim on the island. The image from the anime – Nanao’s trusting face, the sudden, brutal push, the desperate scramble at the cliff edge, the cut rope – it played on a horrifying loop in Arthur’s mind, a constant, unwelcome guest. Every time he saw Nana interacting with Nanao, her expression one of cloying sweetness and deep, manufactured sympathy, a cold dread twisted in his gut. She was a spider, spinning a beautiful, deadly web around the unsuspecting fly.

Arthur made it his unwelcome mission to be Nanao’s inconvenient, awkward shadow. During breaks between classes, he’d find reasons – however flimsy – to be near Nanao, offering stilted, phone-translated observations about the surprisingly aggressive seagulls, or a particularly convoluted problem in their mathematics textbook. Nanao, a painfully shy boy by nature, with a habit of staring at his own feet whenever spoken to, seemed mostly bewildered by the sudden, persistent attention from the quiet, foreign-seeming Tanaka-kun. He was too polite, too timid, to actually rebuff him, but his nervous fidgeting and mumbled, monosyllabic replies made their interactions an exercise in social agony for both of them. Arthur, however, persisted, driven by a desperate urgency.

He knew the cliff incident was typically instigated by Nana preying on Nanao's profound feelings of worthlessness, his crippling lack of self-esteem. She would suggest they go somewhere quiet to talk, somewhere with a "beautiful view" where he could "clear his head." Arthur began to pay obsessive attention to the class schedule, noting the free periods, the lunch breaks, and the well-trodden routes students took to various scenic spots on the island – spots he’d mentally cross-referenced with the hazy, half-remembered visuals from his nephew's anime. The cliffs on the northern side of the island, with their dramatic drop to the churning sea, became a focal point of his dread.

It was a bright, deceptively cheerful Tuesday afternoon, during a longer-than-usual lunch break due to a cancelled afternoon class. Arthur, forcing down a dry bread roll in the noisy canteen, saw Nana approach Nanao’s solitary table. Her smile was particularly dazzling, her body language a study in practiced empathy. He couldn’t hear their conversation from across the crowded room, but Nanao’s slumped shoulders, the way he picked at his food without eating, and Nana’s earnest, head-tilted posture as she leaned in, speaking softly to him, were damningly eloquent. Then, with a gentle, encouraging hand on Nanao’s arm, Nana gestured vaguely in the direction of the northern cliffs. This was it. His stomach plummeted.

His heart hammered against his ribs, a frantic bird trapped in his chest. He had to intercept, but not too obviously. He couldn’t let Nana know he knew her intentions. That would be signing his own death warrant. He had to make it look like an accident, a product of his inconvenient, erratic "Talent."

He waited a minute, a torturous, agonizing sixty seconds, letting them get a head start, then followed, his own tray abandoned. He forced himself to walk at a casual pace, though every instinct screamed at him to run. He took a slightly different, less direct path, one that wound through a small, overgrown copse of whispering bamboo, a route he knew would converge with theirs just before the steeper, more treacherous incline leading to the cliff edge viewing area. The air in the bamboo grove was cool and damp, the rustling leaves sounding like hushed, conspiratorial whispers.

As he rounded a sharp bend, momentarily obscured by a particularly thick clump of bamboo, he saw them. Nana was a few steps ahead, her pink pigtails bouncing, beckoning Nanao forward with a bright, encouraging smile. Nanao was shuffling along behind her, his head bowed, his gaze fixed on the scuffed toes of his shoes, the picture of dejection. Arthur quickened his pace, his timing now critical.

Just as Nana was saying something about the “beautiful, clear view from the top” offering “such a wonderfully fresh perspective on things,” Arthur “accidentally” stumbled out of the bamboo path, his foot catching on an imaginary root. He lurched forward, bumping lightly but decisively into Nanao, who let out a small, startled yelp and stumbled himself.

“Ah, gomen nasai! My apologies! So clumsy of me!” Arthur exclaimed, his voice a little too loud, a little too forced. He quickly typed into his phone, his fingers surprisingly steady despite the adrenaline coursing through him, and held it up so that Nanao – and, crucially, Nana, who had turned at the commotion – could see the screen. “Nanao-san! Tanaka-kun, isn’t it? What a complete coincidence meeting you both here.”

Nana turned fully, her bright smile tightening almost imperceptibly at the edges. Her violet eyes, usually wide with feigned innocence, held a flicker of sharp annoyance. “Tanaka-kun. We were just going up to admire the view. Nakajima-kun was feeling a little down.”

“The view…” Arthur echoed, then he made a deliberate show of his eyes going distant, a slight frown creasing his brow, his head tilting as if listening to something only he could hear – his well-rehearsed charade of his “Talent” kicking in. He reached out, as if instinctively, his fingers brushing lightly against Nanao’s arm. Nanao flinched at the unexpected contact.

“Nanao-san,” Arthur said, his phone translating his low, urgent English words into equally grave Japanese, ensuring Nana, standing just a few feet away, could hear every syllable. “My Talent… it just showed me a flash. A very disturbing one. You… you were falling. From up there.” He gestured vaguely with his free hand towards the cliff edge, hidden from their current vantage point but looming in their immediate future. “Right here. On this path. Today. Please, I implore you, be incredibly careful if you go any further. Perhaps… perhaps it would be better not to go at all today.”

Nanao stared at him, his already pale face draining of all remaining colour. He looked from Arthur’s feigned distress to the path ahead, then back to Arthur, his eyes wide with a dawning, superstitious terror. Nana’s expression was a careful mask of polite concern, but Arthur could see the sharp calculation in her eyes, the way her smile didn’t quite reach them. His “prediction” was specific enough to be deeply alarming to Nanao, yet vague enough to be a lucky, albeit unsettling, coincidence from Nana’s perspective. To dismiss it out of hand, especially after his previous “accurate” forecast of her and Kyouya’s arrival, might look callous, even suspicious, particularly if something did then happen to Nanao. It complicated her plan beautifully.

“Oh my goodness,” Nana said, her voice dripping with a perfectly calibrated mixture of false sympathy and gentle skepticism. “That sounds… simply terrible, Tanaka-kun. Are you quite sure? Sometimes these strong feelings, these… glimpses… can be a little misleading, can’t they?” She was trying to downplay it, to regain control of Nanao, to coax him forward.

“It felt… horribly real, Hiiragi-san,” Arthur insisted gravely via his phone, meeting Nana’s gaze for a brief, challenging moment before turning back to Nanao with an expression of profound, urgent concern. “Perhaps another day would be better for admiring the view, Nanao-san? When the… the premonitions are less active? When the air feels less… fraught?”

Nanao, thoroughly spooked by the vivid image of himself falling from a great height, nodded vehemently, clutching at the excuse like a drowning man grasping a lifeline. “Yes! Yes, you’re right, Tanaka-kun! I… I suddenly remembered I left my history textbook in the classroom. A very important textbook. I should go back and get it. Right now.” He practically bolted, muttering apologies and thanks, scrambling back down the path the way they had come.

Nana was left standing on the path with Arthur, the silence between them thick with unspoken accusations and frustrated intent. Her smile was strained, a mere caricature of its usual brilliance. “Well, Tanaka-kun,” she said, her voice dangerously sweet. “You certainly possess a… most dramatic and timely Talent.”

“It is often more a curse than a blessing, Hiiragi-san,” Arthur’s phone replied, his translated tone suitably sombre and world-weary. He then made his own hasty excuses about needing to find a quieter spot to “clear his head” after such a disturbing “vision,” and retreated in the direction Nanao had fled, leaving Nana standing alone amidst the rustling bamboo, her meticulously planned murder for the day thoroughly, infuriatingly derailed.

He didn’t relax, however, not for a second. Nana was nothing if not persistent. For the rest of that afternoon, and indeed for the next couple of anxious days, Arthur made himself Nanao’s unofficial, relentlessly awkward bodyguard. He sat near him (or as near as Nanao’s discomfort would allow) at lunch, walked with him (or rather, a few paces behind him) between classes, manufacturing reasons to engage him in stilted, phone-mediated conversations about everything and nothing – the difficulty of certain kanji, the surprisingly palatable nature of the canteen’s curry, the migratory patterns of local birds (a topic Arthur knew absolutely nothing about but improvised wildly on). He learned, in brief, mumbled snippets from Nanao, that the boy was passionate about old, obscure strategy video games and surprisingly knowledgeable about the island’s limited local flora.

It was exhausting, maintaining this facade of casual proximity while his nerves were stretched taut as piano wire. Nana watched them, her expression unreadable but her presence a constant, simmering pressure. She made a few more subtle attempts to get Nanao alone, suggesting a visit to the library’s “quiet, secluded annex” for study, or a peaceful walk by the “tranquil, reflective pond” on the far side of the school grounds. But each time, Arthur, with a seemingly coincidental appearance and another vague, unsettling “glimpse” related to the proposed location (“I sense… a sudden, inexplicable chill… a feeling of being trapped, of deep water, near that pond, Nanao-san. Perhaps it is best avoided today?”), managed to thwart her with a maddening, if clumsy, consistency.

His repeated interventions were clearly making Nana increasingly wary of him. She couldn’t act overtly against him without potentially exposing her own malevolent intentions, especially since his “predictions,” however outlandish, kept proving… disturbingly prescient in their negativity, at least in Nanao’s increasingly rattled and grateful mind.

Nanao, for his part, was beginning to see Arthur not just as the “strange, quiet Tanaka-kun” but as some kind of eccentric, slightly frightening, but ultimately benevolent guardian angel. After the third “warning” that seemed to avert some unseen disaster, he’d looked at Arthur with an expression of genuine, almost teary-eyed gratitude.

“Tanaka-kun,” he’d said, his voice barely a whisper, as he nervously offered Arthur a small, slightly bruised apple he’d saved from lunch. “Thank you. I… I don’t know what I would do without your… your warnings. You’ve… you’ve really helped me. More than you know.”

Arthur had simply nodded, accepting the apple with a mumbled thanks of his own (via phone, of course), a complicated mixture of profound relief and gnawing guilt churning within him. He’d saved Nanao, for now. He’d bought him precious time. But in doing so, he had also firmly painted an even larger, brighter target on his own back as far as Nana Hiiragi was concerned. She wouldn’t give up on her mission to eliminate Nanao, and she certainly wouldn’t forget the inconvenient, unpredictable new student with the troublesome, embarrassing, and infuriatingly timed glimpses into the future. The game had just become significantly more dangerous. And Arthur knew, with a certainty that made his blood run cold, that Nana was already recalculating, already planning her next move.

Chapter 22: Mainland Purgatory

The mainland was a brutal, disorienting awakening into a new kind of hell. Stripped of the insular, albeit perilous, structure of the island academy, and now, crucially, without his phone translator which had been casually confiscated by a bored Committee agent during the chaotic disembarkation, Arthur found himself utterly adrift in a sea of indifferent, uncomprehending faces and a language that was now an almost impenetrable barrier. The yen he’d had in “Kenji Tanaka’s” school uniform pockets had been minimal and was quickly exhausted on a few meagre portions of rice balls. He was just another nameless, homeless youth, lost and invisible in the sprawling, pitiless concrete jungle of a large Japanese port city. His limited, halting Japanese, learned through painful necessity on the island, was woefully inadequate for navigating this complex new world.

Days blurred into a miserable, exhausting cycle of gnawing hunger, damp cold, and the constant, weary, often fruitless search for some form of shelter from the elements or a discarded, half-eaten meal in a fast-food restaurant’s overflowing bin. He slept in darkened alleyways that stank of stale urine and rotting garbage, under the echoing concrete arches of bridges, the ever-present fear of discovery by police patrols or less savory, predatory elements of the city’s underbelly a constant, unwelcome companion. He missed Michiru with an ache that was a physical pain in his chest; her quiet presence, her unwavering kindness, their shared, fragile peace during the last island break, had been a small, precious light in his otherwise oppressive darkness. Now, that light was extinguished, and he was stumbling blindly.

A few desperate, soul-crushing weeks into this miserable existence, as he was huddled in a damp shop doorway, trying to escape a biting, persistent late summer rain, a sleek, anonymous black car with tinted windows purred to a silent halt beside him. A man in a sharp, impeccably tailored dark suit emerged, holding a large black umbrella with practiced ease, shielding himself as he approached. He addressed Arthur by his island name, his Japanese precise and formal.

“Tanaka Kenji-kun?” the man inquired, his voice polite but utterly devoid of warmth or inflection, his eyes cold and appraising as they took in Arthur’s ragged, rain-soaked appearance. “My employer has taken an active interest in your current welfare. He understands, through various channels, that you may be… experiencing some temporary difficulties adjusting to mainland life.” He paused, allowing Arthur to absorb the implications of being so easily found. “He is, therefore, prepared to offer you refuge, assistance, a chance to rebuild your life under more… favorable circumstances.”

Arthur stared at the man, then at the opulent, waiting car, a stark symbol of power and influence in this grimy, indifferent street. He didn’t need his phone to translate the chilling intent behind the polite words. This was the Committee. This was Tsuruoka, reaching out with a silken, poisoned glove. “Who… who is your employer?” Arthur managed, his own voice raspy and weak from disuse, the Japanese words clumsy and heavily accented.

“A concerned benefactor,” the man replied smoothly, his expression unchanging. “He believes that Talented individuals like yourself, particularly those who have endured the… unique rigors of the island program, deserve ongoing support and guidance, not abandonment.”

Arthur almost choked on a bitter, hysterical laugh. Support. Guidance. From the very people who ran a death camp for unsuspecting, Talented teenagers. “Tell your ‘concerned benefactor’,” Arthur said, the English words a sudden, angry torrent from his lips, before he caught himself and forced out a stumbling, defiant Japanese reply, “that I… I appreciate the offer… but I prefer to manage my own affairs. I require no assistance.”

The man’s thin lips curved into the faintest, most chilling of smiles. “A most regrettable decision, Tanaka-kun. My employer is not accustomed to having his… generous offers so readily dismissed. This opportunity may not present itself again.” He produced a plain, unmarked white card from his inner pocket, offering it to Arthur. It held a single, untraceable phone number. “Should you reconsider your position.” Then, with a slight, almost imperceptible bow, he returned to his car, which slid silently away into the rain-swept streets, leaving Arthur alone once more, shivering in the damp doorway, the card quickly turning to sodden pulp in his trembling hand. He knew, with absolute certainty, that he’d made the right, the only, choice, but the brief, chilling contact, the effortless demonstration of their reach, left him profoundly shaken and with a renewed sense of being hunted.

Meanwhile, many miles away, Commander Tsuruoka was indeed displeased. Not only had this Kenji Tanaka anomaly refused his "generous" offer of controlled reintegration, but Nana Hiiragi, his once-star asset, was proving increasingly problematic, her operational effectiveness compromised by sentimentality and doubt. During a particularly harsh, psychologically invasive debriefing session following her return from the island after the truncated second year, Tsuruoka informed Nana that her next assignment would be a return to the island academy, with a new, carefully selected intake of students. He then fed her a meticulously constructed, entirely false narrative: “Kenji Tanaka has become a dangerous rogue element, Hiiragi. His so-called prescient abilities are unstable, making him a unpredictable threat. He has evaded all our attempts at compassionate control and assistance. He is now, regrettably, considered a significant threat to the integrity of the program, potentially even to wider national security interests if his abilities fall into the wrong hands. Your primary, non-negotiable objective for the upcoming term will be his swift and permanent elimination. There will be no failures this time. Is that understood?” Nana, still reeling from her own recent traumas and Tsuruoka’s chilling manipulations regarding Mai, had listened with a pale face, her mind a maelstrom of conflicting emotions and a growing, terrifying dread. Arthur, a threat to national security? The haunted, weary boy who had so tenderly cared for Michiru’s lifeless body? It didn’t track, not at all, yet Tsuruoka’s orders were absolute, backed by the implicit threat of unimaginable consequences should she disobey.

Arthur, entirely oblivious to Nana’s new, horrifying directive concerning him, eventually, through sheer, desperate persistence, found work. It was grueling, back-breaking, spirit-crushing labour on a sprawling construction site on the city’s outskirts, hauling bags of cement, shoveling rubble, mixing concrete under the relentless summer sun. The pay was insultingly minimal, barely enough for a shared, flea-ridden bunk in a crowded, squalid flophouse that reeked of stale sweat and cheap alcohol, and a daily bowl of watery, tasteless noodles. His days became a monotonous, exhausting blur of brutal physical exertion and profound mental despair. He was Kenji Tanaka, anonymous construction grunt, his past life as Arthur Ainsworth, respected (if unfulfilled) accounts clerk, a fading, almost unbelievable dream; his time on the island, with its constant terror but also its strange, intense connections, a recurring, vivid nightmare. He thought often, achingly, of Michiru, wondering where the Committee had taken her, if she was safe, if he would ever see her gentle smile again. The hope of it was a distant, flickering, almost extinguished candle in the vast darkness of his current existence. The irony of his current occupation, he sometimes thought with a bitter twist of his lips, was that this was the kind of life Kyouya Onodera had apparently endured before his own arrival on that cursed island.

His miserable reprieve, such as it was, didn’t last. One sweltering evening, as he trudged wearily back towards the dubious sanctuary of the flophouse, his body aching from head to toe, his spirit numb with exhaustion, a dark, unmarked van screeched to a halt beside him on the deserted, dusty road. Before he could even register the threat, before he could think to run, several grim-faced figures in plain, dark clothes erupted from its sliding door and bundled him inside with brutal, practiced efficiency. He struggled instinctively, a desperate, futile thrashing, but they were strong, their movements coordinated, their grips like iron. A rough cloth, smelling faintly of chemicals, was pressed hard over his face, a sweet, cloying, sickeningly artificial scent filled his nostrils, and the ugly, indifferent world dissolved into a suffocating, unwelcome blackness.

He awoke, gagging and disoriented, in a bare, sterile, windowless room, strapped tightly to a hard metal chair. A single, painfully bright spotlight shone directly into his face, making him squint. Tsuruoka himself wasn’t present – Arthur was clearly not yet deemed worthy of the commander’s personal attention for this particular stage of his “re-education” – but a subordinate, a cold-eyed, stern-faced woman in a severe, dark military-style uniform, stood before him, her arms crossed, her expression devoid of any discernible emotion.

“Tanaka Kenji,” she stated, her voice flat, impersonal, chillingly devoid of inflection. She consulted a thin file in her hand. “Or perhaps, given your rather… unusual background, you currently prefer the designation Arthur Ainsworth?” She didn’t elaborate on how they might know his original name; the casual, confident implication of their far-reaching, invasive intelligence network was, in itself, a potent form of intimidation. “You have proven to be a persistent, and rather tiresome, inconvenience, Mr. Ainsworth. You were given a generous opportunity to cooperate with our organization. You unwisely declined.”

She took a step closer, her shadow falling over him. “Our organization has a significant, long-term investment in the island program, and its successful outcomes. Uncontrolled, unpredictable variables such as yourself cannot, and will not, be tolerated indefinitely. You will be returning to the island academy for the next academic year, with the new intake of students.” Her lips curved into a smile that held no warmth, only a cold, clinical menace. “Consider this your final opportunity to demonstrate your potential utility to the Committee. Or, failing that,” her smile widened fractionally, “to be… neutralized, shall we say, in a more controlled, predictable, and entirely deniable environment. The choice, as they say, is yours. Though, I suspect, largely illusory.”

Arthur said nothing. There was nothing left to say. He was trapped, a terrified, exhausted pawn being forcibly moved back onto the bloodstained, treacherous board.

The journey back to the island was a disorienting, humiliating blur of sedatives, blindfolds, and the gruff, dispassionate presence of his Committee guards. When he finally stumbled off the transport vessel onto the chillingly familiar pier, the sight of the imposing school buildings, nestled amidst the island’s unnervingly lush, verdant landscape, filled him with a profound, soul-deep sense of dread and utter resignation. A new intake of students, fresh, innocent faces full of naive hope or nervous apprehension, were already disembarking from another, larger ferry, their excited chatter a grotesque counterpoint to his own internal despair. The Third School Year was about to begin, and Arthur Ainsworth knew, with a terrifying, inescapable certainty, that he was now not just an unwilling observer or a clumsy, desperate interferer, but a designated, marked target. And this time, he had no phone, no easy means of communication, and very few allies left.

Heh

10 posts!

Chapter 34: Echoes of a Fictional Past

The fire in the damp cave spat a shower of angry orange sparks into the heavy, charged silence that followed Arthur Ainsworth’s almost whispered, yet cataclysmic, question. The only other sound was the distant, ceaseless roar of the hidden waterfall, a monotonous, indifferent rush of water that suddenly felt like the rushing, uncaring torrent of a reality that had just been irrevocably, terrifyingly, and perhaps even liberatingly, undone. Nana Hiiragi stared at him, her violet eyes wide, her face utterly drained of colour, the half-sketched map forgotten in her lap. Kyouya Onodera’s hand had frozen midway through sharpening his makeshift blade, his usually impassive features now a mask of stunned, almost incredulous intensity. Michiru Inukai’s gentle face was etched with profound confusion and a dawning, childlike distress, her hand instinctively going to her mouth. Even Jin Tachibana, for the first time since Arthur had known him, looked momentarily, almost imperceptibly, thrown, his enigmatic smile faltering, his pale eyes fixed on Arthur with a new, sharp, unreadable intensity.

It was Nana who finally broke the spell, her voice a strangled, disbelieving whisper. “A… a story? You’re saying… everything? The island… the killings… me… it was all just… a story you read? In a… a comic book?” The sheer, insane absurdity of it seemed to overwhelm her. The carefully constructed narrative of her life, her suffering, her crimes – all reduced to pulp fiction in another world.

Arthur nodded miserably, the weight of their collective shock almost a physical blow. “Essentially, yes, Hiiragi-san. A manga, as they call them. And then an animated television series. ‘Talentless Nana’. It was… surprisingly popular for a while, in my time. Known for its dark themes, its psychological twists.” He felt a flush of shame, of acute discomfort. How could he possibly explain the ghoulish voyeurism of it all? Their real, lived pain, packaged as entertainment. It felt obscene.

Kyouya Onodera finally moved, placing his sharpened metal shard down with slow, deliberate precision. His voice, when he spoke, was dangerously quiet, each word a carefully chipped piece of ice. “So all your ‘predictions,’ Tanaka-kun… or should I say, Ainsworth-san? Your ‘Chrono-Empathic Glimpse’… your knowledge of our Talents, our weaknesses, our… our fates… it all came from this… this fictional narrative?”

“Most of it,” Arthur admitted, his gaze dropping to the cave floor. He couldn’t meet Kyouya’s piercing stare. “My memories of it are… fragmented. Incomplete. Like trying to recall a dream years later. I remembered key events, character traits, some of the deaths. Enough to make those ‘predictions.’ Enough to try and… interfere, sometimes successfully, often not.” He thought of the sheer, unmitigated unreality of it all, more like some bizarre, avant-garde play one might see in a small, underfunded provincial theatre back in Sussex, something designed to shock and confuse, than any lived experience.

“So you knew,” Nana’s voice was stronger now, laced with a dawning, terrible anger, a profound sense of betrayal. “You knew what I was. What I would do. You knew about… about Michiru?” Her gaze flicked towards the fluffy-haired girl, who was now looking at Arthur with wide, wounded eyes.

“I knew… some of it,” Arthur said wretchedly. “I knew Michiru was… important. I knew she had a powerful healing Talent. I remembered… I remembered her dying to save you, Nana-san, in the story. That’s why I tried so desperately to stop her at the docks.” He looked at Michiru. “And later, why I hoped… her body being warm, it matched some obscure detail I half-recalled about how truly powerful healing Talents might interact with death in your world, according to the lore of that story.”

Michiru’s eyes filled with tears. “So… my life… Nana-chan’s life… it was all… written down somewhere?” she whispered, her voice trembling.

“In my world, yes,” Arthur confirmed, his own voice hoarse with a mixture of guilt and a strange, weary resignation. “A fiction. Here… here it’s your reality. Our reality now, I suppose.”

“Why didn’t you stop more of it?” Kyouya’s question was sharp, cutting as the blade he’d just been honing. “If you possessed such… supposedly comprehensive foreknowledge, why allow so many to die? Why not expose Nana from the outset?”

Arthur finally looked up, a spark of his old, tired frustration igniting in his eyes as he met Kyouya’s accusatory gaze. “Do you truly think I didn’t want to?” he retorted, his voice gaining a raw, defensive edge. “My memory of this… this ‘story’… it was never comprehensive, Kyouya-san. It was like a shattered mirror, reflecting only fragments, often distorted, often out of sequence. I frequently didn’t know the when or even the exact where each murder or critical event would take place until it was almost upon us, or sometimes, tragically, not until it was too late.”

He took a ragged breath, the faces of the dead flickering before his mind’s eye. “Take Nanao Nakajima, for instance. I knew where Nana planned to kill him – that cliff by the sea. It was a very vivid scene in the story. But I had no idea when she would make her move – which day, which hour. I had to shadow him for days, make a nuisance of myself, an utter fool, just waiting, hoping I could intervene at the right, critical moment. With Yuusuke Tachibana, the time traveler,” Arthur continued, his voice tight with the memory of that particularly cold-blooded murder, “again, I knew where – the lake. But not when. My warning to him was vague because my knowledge was vague. I couldn’t tell him ‘Nana will drown you by the old boathouse next Tuesday at 3 PM’ because I simply didn’t know that level of detail.”

He looked down at his hands, clenching and unclenching them. “And Touichirou Hoshino, the poor boy dying of cancer… for him, I didn’t even have an accurate location. Just a hazy recollection from the story that it was possibly in a cave somewhere on the island. Which cave? When? The story never specified. I tried to find him, to warn him, but the island is large, and he was already reclusive due to his illness.” Arthur shook his head, the weight of these specific failures, these agonizing limitations, pressing down on him.

“And what if I had tried to change things too drastically from the outset?” he pressed on, his voice gaining a note of desperation. “What if I’d stood up on that first day and announced, ‘Nana Hiiragi is a government assassin, and here’s a list of everyone she’s going to kill’? Who would have believed me? They’d have locked me up as a lunatic! Or Nana herself would have eliminated me before I drew my next breath. The story I remembered was horrific, yes, but what if my blundering attempts to play God based on a half-recalled comic book from another dimension made things even worse? Created new, unforeseen tragedies? New victims I couldn’t have predicted?” He gestured helplessly. “And frankly, Kyouya-san, I was terrified. Most of the time, I am terrified. I was alone, in a foreign land I didn’t understand, in a body that wasn’t mine, surrounded by people with often terrifying superhuman abilities, one of whom was a highly trained, remorseless assassin systematically killing everyone around me. My primary concern, I’ll admit it freely, was often my own desperate survival, and simply trying to make some kind of rudimentary sense of an utterly impossible, insane situation.”

He turned to Nana, whose face was a maelstrom of conflicting emotions – anger, betrayal, confusion, but also, Arthur thought he saw, a flicker of something else, something akin to a strange, twisted validation. If her life, her actions, had been “scripted” in some other dimension, did that lessen her own culpability? Did it make Tsuruoka’s manipulation even more monstrously profound?

“And what,” Jin Tachibana finally spoke, his voice still calm, still enigmatic, though his eyes held a new, sharp alertness, “does this… ‘story’… say happens next? Now that we have escaped this camp? Now that your ‘Talent,’ your foreknowledge of our specific immediate actions, is supposedly… depleted?”

Arthur shook his head. “That’s the problem. The story I remember… it focused primarily on Nana’s time on the island during that first year. It detailed many of her… assignments. It touched upon Kyouya’s investigation, Michiru’s sacrifice and return, the conflict with Rentaro. After that, my knowledge becomes… patchy. Vague. I remember broader strokes about Tsuruoka, about the Committee, about the ‘Enemies of Humanity,’ about a growing societal fear of Talents leading to… to situations like this internment camp.” He gestured around the damp cave. “But specific events? Timelines? Who lives, who dies from this point on? I have no idea. The narrative, for me, largely ended with the first year’s major events, or became too divergent from what I was experiencing once I started interfering. From the moment Michiru first returned, from Nana’s breakdown at the cliff, things here have already been… different, diverging significantly from what I dimly recalled. My foreknowledge of your specific futures, your day-to-day choices, is gone. As I said, I’m as blind as the rest of you now.”

A new, uneasy silence descended. The implications of Arthur’s confession, the sheer, mind-bending audacity of it, were immense, earth-shattering. Their lives, their struggles, their very identities, mirrored, however imperfectly, in a work of popular fiction from another world, another time. It was a truth so outlandish, so existentially terrifying, it was almost impossible to fully grasp.

It was Michiru, her gentle voice trembling but surprisingly firm, who finally voiced the question that hung heavy and unspoken in the damp, smoky air. “So, Arthur-san… if our lives here are… were… a story in your world… does that mean we are not truly real? That our pain… our choices… that they don’t truly matter in the grand scheme of things?”

Arthur looked at her, his heart aching at her innocent, profound, and utterly heartbreaking question. “No, Michiru-san,” he said, his voice thick with an emotion he couldn’t quite name – a fierce protectiveness, a profound empathy. “No. Absolutely not. What happens here, what you feel, what you choose to do every single day… it is absolutely, terrifyingly, undeniably real. Perhaps, in many ways, it is even more real than anything I ever experienced in my own, mundane world. The story… it was just a flawed, incomplete window, a distorted mirror reflecting a sliver of your reality. It doesn’t define you. It doesn’t negate your suffering, or your courage, or your capacity for love and sacrifice.”

He looked around at their stunned, searching faces, lit by the flickering, unreliable firelight. He had laid himself bare, revealed his most unbelievable, his most vulnerable, his most insane truth. He felt strangely light, as if a tremendous, crushing burden had finally been lifted from his shoulders, but also terrified of their judgment, their potential rejection, their understandable disbelief.

It was Nana, surprisingly, who broke the heavy tension. She let out a long, shuddering breath, then, a small, hysterical, almost broken laugh escaped her lips, a sound utterly devoid of mirth. “A comic book…” she whispered, shaking her head in stunned, almost numb disbelief. “All this… all this horror… all this blood… because of a damned comic book character who just happens to look like me…” She looked directly at Arthur, and for the very first time since he had met her, he saw not anger, not betrayal, not even suspicion, but a flicker of something akin to a weary, horrified, almost surreal camaraderie. “Well, Ainsworth-san,” she said, her voice raw, cracked, almost unrecognizable. “It seems your life is, if anything, even stranger, even more unbelievable, than ours.”

Kyouya Onodera nodded slowly, his gaze distant, contemplative. “Indeed. This revelation… it re-contextualizes everything. Your past actions, your warnings… your apparent foreknowledge.” He paused, his sharp eyes meeting Arthur’s. “It also suggests that if such a narrative existed, then perhaps our struggles, our very existence, have some form of… pre-ordained pattern, even if you, personally, no longer have access to its specific details. Or, perhaps, and this is the more pertinent consideration, it offers us the definitive chance to consciously, deliberately break from it. To write our own ending.”

The future, which had always been a terrifying, oppressive unknown for Arthur despite his supposed “Talent,” now felt even more vast, more unpredictable, but also, strangely, more laden with a desperate, shared, and almost defiant agency. They were no longer just characters in a half-remembered story he carried within him like a curse. They were survivors, together, facing a monstrous, common enemy, armed now with not just their varied Talents and their hard-won courage, but with the most bizarre, the most unbelievable, the most world-shattering truth imaginable. Where they went from here, what they chose to do with this impossible knowledge, was now, truly, terrifyingly, and perhaps even liberatingly, up to them.

“Most of it,” Arthur admitted, his gaze dropping to the cave floor. He couldn’t meet Kyouya’s piercing stare. “My memories of it are… fragmented. Incomplete. Like trying to recall a dream years later. I remembered key events, character traits, some of the deaths. Enough to make those ‘predictions.’ Enough to try and… interfere, sometimes successfully, often not.” He thought of the sheer, unmitigated unreality of it all, more like some bizarre, avant-garde play one might see in a small festival theatre back in Sussex, something designed to shock and confuse, than any lived experience.

“So you knew,” Nana’s voice was stronger now, laced with a dawning, terrible anger, a profound sense of betrayal. “You knew what I was. What I would do. You knew about… about Michiru?” Her gaze flicked towards the fluffy-haired girl, who was now looking at Arthur with wide, wounded eyes.

“I knew… some of it,” Arthur said wretchedly. “I knew Michiru was… important. I knew she had a powerful healing Talent. I remembered… I remembered her dying to save you, Nana-san, in the story. That’s why I tried so desperately to stop her at the docks.” He looked at Michiru. “And later, why I hoped… her body being warm, it matched some obscure detail I half-recalled about how truly powerful healing Talents might interact with death in your world, according to the lore of that story.”

Michiru’s eyes filled with tears. “So… my life… Nana-chan’s life… it was all… written down somewhere?” she whispered, her voice trembling.

“In my world, yes,” Arthur confirmed, his own voice hoarse with a mixture of guilt and a strange, weary resignation. “A fiction. Here… here it’s your reality. Our reality now, I suppose.”

“Why didn’t you stop more of it?” Kyouya’s question was sharp, cutting. “If you possessed such… comprehensive foreknowledge, why allow so many to die? Why not expose Nana from the outset?”

Arthur finally looked up, meeting Kyouya’s accusatory gaze. “Do you think I didn’t want to?” he retorted, a flash of his old, tired frustration surfacing. “My memory was imperfect, like I said. I often only remembered crucial details moments before they were due to happen, if at all. And what if I had tried to change things too drastically? The story I remembered was horrific, yes, but what if my interference, my blundering attempts to play God based on a half-recalled comic book, made things even worse? Created new, unforeseen tragedies? And frankly, Kyouya-san, I was terrified. I was alone, in a foreign land, in a body that wasn’t mine, surrounded by people with superhuman abilities, one of whom was a trained assassin systematically killing everyone around me. My primary concern, I’ll admit it, was often my own survival, and trying to make sense of an impossible situation.”

He turned to Nana, whose face was a maelstrom of conflicting emotions – anger, betrayal, confusion, but also, Arthur thought he saw, a flicker of something else, something akin to a strange, twisted validation. If her life, her actions, had been “scripted” in some other dimension, did that lessen her own culpability? Did it make Tsuruoka’s manipulation even more monstrous?

“And what,” Jin Tachibana finally spoke, his voice still calm, still enigmatic, though his eyes held a new, sharp alertness, “does this… ‘story’… say happens next? Now that we have escaped this camp? Now that your ‘Talent,’ your foreknowledge of our specific immediate actions, is supposedly… depleted?”

Arthur shook his head. “That’s the problem. The story I remember… it focused primarily on Nana’s time on the island during that first year. It detailed many of her… assignments. It touched upon Kyouya’s investigation, Michiru’s sacrifice and return, the conflict with Rentaro. After that, my knowledge becomes… patchy. Vague. I remember broader strokes about Tsuruoka, about the Committee, about the ‘Enemies of Humanity,’ about a growing societal fear of Talents leading to… to situations like this internment camp.” He gestured around the damp cave. “But specific events? Timelines? Who lives, who dies from this point on? I have no idea. The narrative, for me, largely ended with the first year’s major events, or became too divergent from what I was experiencing once I started interfering. From the moment Michiru first returned, from Nana’s breakdown at the cliff, things here have already been… different, diverging significantly from what I dimly recalled.”

He paused, then added a crucial detail, his gaze shifting, almost reluctantly, towards Nana Hiiragi, who was watching him with a disturbing, unreadable intensity. “There’s something else about this… this ‘story’ you should know. It’s… or rather, it was… ongoing. Or at least, it was still being written, still being released, just before I… before I arrived here. I never read or saw the absolute end of it, because it hadn't been created yet in my time.”

He saw a flicker of something – hope? Dread? – in Nana’s eyes. “And Nana-san,” Arthur continued, choosing his words very carefully, the Japanese feeling heavy and inadequate for what he was trying to convey, “in the version of the story I knew, your character… she begins to change. Profoundly. After certain events, after certain realizations about Tsuruoka and the Committee… she starts… she starts trying to save Talents, not eliminate them.”

Nana’s breath hitched, an almost inaudible gasp. Kyouya’s head tilted slightly, his analytical gaze sharpening further.

“In fact,” Arthur pressed on, remembering the dark, vengeful turn the fictional Nana had taken, “the Nana in the manga… she wants nothing more than to, well…” He hesitated, searching for a way to translate a rather brutal English idiom. He pictured, for a fleeting, absurd moment, the old, battered woodchipper his neighbour in Crawley, old Mr. Henderson, used with noisy relish on his garden waste every autumn. “She wants to ram Tsuruoka into a… a proverbial woodchipper.” He made a crude, forceful pushing and grinding motion with his hands, then quickly dropped them, flushing slightly at the inadequacy of the gesture. “She wants to see him utterly, completely destroyed. And she’d undoubtedly go through every last member of The Committee to do so, to make them all pay for what they did to her, to everyone.”

He looked around at their stunned faces. “As for anyone else in the story… Kyouya-san, Michiru-san, Jin-san… what their ultimate fates were according to that unfinished narrative… I genuinely don’t know. My memory focuses mostly on… on Nana’s arc, as she was the titular character.”

A new, even heavier silence descended upon the cave, thick with the implications of this latest, astonishing revelation. The idea that Nana Hiiragi, their island’s most feared and prolific killer, was “destined” in some other-worldly fiction to become a savior, a destroyer of the very system that had created her, was almost too much to comprehend.

It was Michiru, her gentle voice trembling but firm, who finally voiced the question that hung heavy and unspoken in the damp, smoky air. “So, Arthur-san… if our lives here are… were… a story in your world… does that mean we are not truly real? That our pain… our choices… that they don’t truly matter in the grand scheme of things?”

Arthur looked at her, his heart aching at her innocent, profound, and utterly heartbreaking question. “No, Michiru-san,” he said, his voice thick with an emotion he couldn’t quite name – a fierce protectiveness, a profound empathy. “No. Absolutely not. What happens here, what you feel, what you choose to do every single day… it is absolutely, terrifyingly, undeniably real. Perhaps, in many ways, it is even more real than anything I ever experienced in my own, mundane world. The story… it was just a flawed, incomplete window, a distorted mirror reflecting a sliver of your reality. It doesn’t define you. It doesn’t negate your suffering, or your courage, or your capacity for love and sacrifice.”

He looked around at their stunned, searching faces, lit by the flickering, unreliable firelight. He had laid himself bare, revealed his most unbelievable, his most vulnerable, his most insane truth. He felt strangely light, as if a tremendous, crushing burden had finally been lifted from his shoulders, but also terrified of their judgment, their potential rejection, their understandable disbelief.

It was Nana, surprisingly, who broke the heavy tension. She let out a long, shuddering breath, then, a small, hysterical, almost broken laugh escaped her lips, a sound utterly devoid of mirth. “A comic book…” she whispered, shaking her head in stunned, almost numb disbelief. “All this… all this horror… all this blood… because of a damned comic book character who just happens to look like me… and who then, apparently, decides to go after Tsuruoka like a… a human woodchipper?” She looked directly at Arthur, and for the very first time since he had met her, he saw not anger, not betrayal, not even suspicion, but a flicker of something akin to a weary, horrified, almost surreal camaraderie. “Well, Ainsworth-san,” she said, her voice raw, cracked, almost unrecognizable. “It seems your life is, if anything, even stranger, even more unbelievable, than ours.”

Kyouya Onodera nodded slowly, his gaze distant, contemplative. “Indeed. This revelation… it re-contextualizes everything. Your past actions, your warnings… your apparent foreknowledge.” He paused, his sharp eyes meeting Arthur’s. “It also suggests that if such a narrative existed, then perhaps our struggles, our very existence, have some form of… pre-ordained pattern, even if you, personally, no longer have access to its specific details. Or, perhaps, and this is the more pertinent consideration,” his gaze flicked briefly towards Nana, then back to Arthur, “it offers us the definitive chance to consciously, deliberately break from it. Or, for some, to perhaps… embrace a different version of their scripted path.”

The future, which had always been a terrifying, oppressive unknown for Arthur despite his supposed “Talent,” now felt even more vast, more unpredictable, but also, strangely, more laden with a desperate, shared, and almost defiant agency. They were no longer just characters in a half-remembered story he carried within him like a curse. They were survivors, together, facing a monstrous, common enemy, armed now with not just their varied Talents and their hard-won courage, but with the most bizarre, the most unbelievable, the most world-shattering truth imaginable. Where they went from here, what they chose to do with this impossible knowledge, was now, truly, terrifyingly, and perhaps even liberatingly, up to them.