Yes! Jon mentioned survival bias in TMA, because all but a few statements were made by those who survived the Horrors long enough to visit the Institute. But it seems like more of the characters here did not survive.
Thinking about how a lot of theorizing about the Magnus protocols has been considering tma statements as about fear whereas tmagp statements are about desires BUT Iβm wondering if this is more about likeβ¦ selection bias?
Think about it- the Magnus archives collected statements from people who volunteered - people who were frightened and then heard of an archive that collects spooky statements. whereas the OIAR system scours the internet so itβs not biased by who was scared enough to go to the Archives.
Thinking seriously about the taxonomy of goths
Straight up I'd kill and die for archivist alice
Like, at first all her spooky shit is a joke
Then life imitates art and she can actually destroy you
there's something inside you it's hard to explain
Oh, how much pain Jonny Sims has planned. I'm pretty pessimistic about Jon & Martin surviving "intact." Best case I can imagine, they've become something new - maybe a rare benevolent entity, even.
I like this interpretation! I'm thinking the Magnus Institute is not the problem. The problem is what left it - all those papers, gone.
Previously the statements were how the Eye fed, but the tape web of recorded statements was how the fears got exported to another world.
So if the statements escaped the Institute, maybe that's a Pandora's Box?
To be fair, Red canary also brought back a box π§
can't stop thinking about red canary.
Like it has to be a red herring+mine canary symbology combo. It's meant to send us on the wrong path. AND it's a serious warning. So the institute IS a genuine danger, but it's not the place to get answers? Do we interpret it as a message to the listeners or the characters?
π³οΈβπ π₯ π³οΈβπ π₯ π³οΈβπ π₯ π³οΈβπ π₯ π³οΈβπ π₯
IN THE HORRIBLE TIKTOK TEXT TO SPEECH VOICE
"hEre's how I lost my eye!!" πππ
so. we know that TMAGP is set in 2024. so far we have seen blog posts, forum posts, cctv, an e-mail. and we know that instagram live exists in universe.
How much time until we get a statement via tiktok storytime?
I love this scene but the whole time her jacket says:
PUNKY FISH
In the most "I'm the fun one" font
(x)
TMAGP 9 SPOILERS
I have a bad feeling Freddy is using the voices of Jon, Martin, and whoever else to goad Sam into returning to the Magnus Institute. And that Jon & Martin are, in fact, completely dead.
image ids under the cut
tmagp 4:
tmagp 5:
tmagp 7:
tmagp 8:
the audio distorts when people lie.
I imagine this knowledge will come in handy later.
[id: ALICE: This is not something you go poking around in. Not if you want to keep your job⦠or your neck. SAM: (a little amused) Okay, okay! I get it. Consider me scared straight. "Consider me scared straight" is highlighted. end id]
[id: LENA: Now, while I understand your concerns, you need to understand that Colin has held the IT Manager position for some time without incident, and although he is somewhat⦠frustrated with his current assignment, he can request help from the central IT team at any time. I am certain that should he find his responsibilities unmanageable, he will request assistance. Or resign, of course. Either way, the problem will resolve itself. "Or resign, of course" is highlighted. end id]
[id: CELIA: Is there any way to look up specific files? ALICE: Like what? CELIA: Oh, I donβt know. Every case aboutβ¦ being buried alive, or meat, orβ¦ whatever. ALICE: Well, thereβs a search bar, but it doesnβt actually do anything. Youβd have to dig through them all manually. (suspicious) β Why do you ask? CELIA: Just figuring it all out. Ah well, I guess Iβll need to find Bigfoot on my own time. "Just figuring it all out" is highlighted. end id]
[id: GERTRUDE: I see. Well, Iβm sorry, but I donβt think Gerry can help you β GERRY: (casually) Yeah, I barely remember any of it. "I donβt think Gerry can help you" is highlighted. end id]
[id: GERRY: Oh yeah, but I was pretty young. I remember filling in a bunch of forms and questionnaires, then some old men asking me questions about what books I liked to read, who did I look up to, that kind of thing. And then I left. SAM: (disappointed) Thatβs all? GERRY: Yeah, afraid so. Other than just sitting around with a bunch of other kids in a room that smelled like old books. "Yeah, afraid so" is highlighted. end id]
[id: CELIA: Iβm trying to look intoβ¦ Weird physics stuff: time travel, other dimensions, teleportation, all that good stuff. Freddy doesnβt really do searches, so you could keep an eye out and let me know if any come up in your cases? SAM: Uh, sounds a bit sci-fi compared to our usuals. Whatβs this for? (amused breath) Youβre not doing research for that podcast you were on, are you? CELIA: (surprised) You know about that? SAM: I might have given you a quick Google. CELIA: Thenβ¦ yeah. Iβm doing a favor for Georgie. "yeah. Iβm doing a favor for Georgie" is highlighted. end id]