A New Question For The Jury: Did My Brain Implant Make Me Do It? « The Jury Room

A New Question For The Jury: Did My Brain Implant Make Me Do It? « The Jury Room

A new question for the jury: Did my brain implant make me do it? « The Jury Room

We’ve written as lot about “brain malfunction” [aka “did my brain make me do it?”] defenses here but this is a new twist on the neurolaw question. Deep brain stimulation (“DBS”) is a well-accepted treatment for a number of serious and treatment resistant neurological conditions from Parkinson’s Disease to depression and obsessive-compulsive disorder. As effective as DBS can be, there are also concerns about how, in some patients, it changes one’s personality to cause “undesirable or even deviant behavior”. The behavioral/personality changes depend on the location of the deep brain stimulation (and the functions carried out by that portion of the brain). 

So. You have a condition for which everyday treatment is ineffective or causes side-effects worse than the condition itself. Your doctor suggests a brain implant to offer deep brain stimulation (DBS). You are unfortunately, one of those for whom DBS creates behavioral reactions and you do something illegal. Are you responsible? Or is it your brain implant? […]

The article is very complex and the ideas in it are provocative. We cannot do justice to the questions raised by these writers in a brief blog post. It’s a very serious question.

"When you agree to a cutting-edge treatment and you are informed that for some people, behavioral changes may occur, do you thereby accept responsibility for any actions you take under the influence of that treatment?

"Or, since the behavior is completely different than anything you have previously displayed  and is thus believed due to the treatment (which can be shut off) is it fair to deny responsibility?

"And if you encounter aberrant behavioral effects but decide to not shut off the DBS because you appreciate the ways in which it helps you function, are you then more responsible for any illegal act you committed since you are choosing to continue down the same path?"

Yes. This is a new question. Not, “did my brain make me do it?” but “did my brain implant make me do it?”. Ultimately, however, the larger question remains the same. Where does our personal responsibility end?

More Posts from Prasannachoudhary and Others

1 month ago

“Two centuries ago, a former European colony took it into its head to catch up with Europe. It has been so successful that the United States of America has become a monster where the flaws, sickness, and inhumanity of Europe have reached frightening proportions.”

— Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth

9 years ago
IMG_7809 By Pooja Pant

IMG_7809 by Pooja Pant

12 years ago
Tiger Bay, Cardiff, 1950, Bert Hardy

Tiger Bay, Cardiff, 1950, Bert Hardy

12 years ago
It All Comes Down To That Urge To Fascism — Maybe A Big Word To Use For Art, But I Think The Right

It all comes down to that urge to fascism — maybe a big word to use for art, but I think the right word — it comes down to that urge to fascism to know what’s best for people, to know that some people are of the best and some people are of the worst; the urge to separate the good from the bad and to praise oneself; to decide what covers on what books people ought to read, what songs people ought to be moved by, what art they ought to make, an urge that makes art into a set of laws that take away your freedom rather than a kind of activity that creates freedom or reveals it. It all comes down to the notion that, in the end, there is a social explanation for art, which is to say an explanation of what kind of art you should be ashamed of and what kind of art you should be proud of. It’s the reduction of the mystery of art, where it comes from, where it goes… 

9 years ago
Untitled By Ivana Stojakovic

Untitled by Ivana Stojakovic

5 years ago
We Are Ruled By Wizards
Bending reality is as simple as bending people’s perception of reality. Throughout history, the mythology of civilizations around the world has been full of tales of men and women who mastere…

Bending reality is as simple as bending people’s perception of reality. Throughout history, the mythology of civilizations around the world has been full of tales of men and women who mastered a mysterious, esoteric art which enabled them to use language in a way that […]

12 years ago

"In India all religions hold in common the idea of two indivisible elements, a male and female principle, Purusha and Prakrti, or Shiva and Shakti. The two elements originate in a single primordial being which manifests a 'desire to create'. From a unitary state of repose this emergent, but creative, tension gives birth to the universe and the multiplicity of beings and things of this world in a state of unceasing instability and flux, of time and constant change, of birth, reproduction, decay, death and rebirth. Out of a permanent coition of opposites the many are born, and with them confusion, antagonism, separateness. But the universe longs to regain its primordial state of oneness, and seeks to reverse the fragmentation. The return path, or restoration of lost unity, is the business of religion, yoga, ritualized sex, and its opposite : rigorous asceticism. These comprise a tool-kit of diverse, and divergent, religious techniques."

Richard Lannoy and Harry Baines, 'The Eye of Love', Grove Press, Inc., New York, 1976.

5 years ago

Elif Shafak on multiculturalism, the power of stories and making the pol...

11 years ago
R I P

R I P

Suchitra Sen (06.04.1931 - 17.01.2014)

Born Roma Dasgupta at Pabna, Bangladesh.

Some of her memorable films: Devdas (1955), Deep Jwele Jaai (1959), Saptapadi (1961), Uttar Falguni (1963), Saat Paake Bandha (1963). Mamta (1966), Aandhi (1975).

Photo: www.thehindu.com 

11 years ago

Insanity: inside the Country of the Mind

Insanity: inside the Country of the Mind

Originally posted on Living in the Modem World:

Insanity

In his novel Queen ofAngels, set at the close of 2047, Greg Bear explores the concept of what he calls, “the Country of the Mind”. This, Bear postulates, is the “ground” for all our thoughts. A kind of virtual reality landscape within us where our “big and little selves” – the personality routines which make up the conscious self, and…

View On WordPress

  • conciliatoryfabrications
    conciliatoryfabrications reblogged this · 6 years ago
  • uroppostdigitalarchitecture-blog
    uroppostdigitalarchitecture-blog reblogged this · 8 years ago
  • mediahater
    mediahater reblogged this · 8 years ago
  • theoreticalconstruct
    theoreticalconstruct liked this · 9 years ago
  • shippingtech-blog
    shippingtech-blog reblogged this · 9 years ago
  • blackydale
    blackydale reblogged this · 10 years ago
  • blackydale
    blackydale liked this · 10 years ago
  • cidham
    cidham liked this · 10 years ago
  • ifyourelisteningurtheresistance
    ifyourelisteningurtheresistance reblogged this · 10 years ago
  • forever-paradise-x
    forever-paradise-x reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • gyaljay
    gyaljay liked this · 11 years ago
  • umborobot
    umborobot reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • umborobot
    umborobot liked this · 11 years ago
  • destroytype-blog
    destroytype-blog liked this · 11 years ago
  • serendipityschild
    serendipityschild reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • serendipityschild
    serendipityschild liked this · 11 years ago
  • rr5001
    rr5001 liked this · 11 years ago
  • ehugs
    ehugs liked this · 11 years ago
  • doctorfrankenmonster-blog
    doctorfrankenmonster-blog liked this · 11 years ago
  • old-timers-dis-ease
    old-timers-dis-ease reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • 8streetlightsshinelikestars-blog
    8streetlightsshinelikestars-blog reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • femmeviva
    femmeviva liked this · 11 years ago
  • bigaznboi
    bigaznboi reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • bigaznboi
    bigaznboi liked this · 11 years ago
  • doktorloy
    doktorloy reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • themcginny
    themcginny reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • themcginny
    themcginny liked this · 11 years ago
  • julianstahnke
    julianstahnke reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • piotrek-xd
    piotrek-xd liked this · 11 years ago
  • short-for-bob
    short-for-bob reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • theshadoutmapes
    theshadoutmapes liked this · 11 years ago
  • poeticdiscontent
    poeticdiscontent liked this · 11 years ago
  • therenegadedj
    therenegadedj liked this · 11 years ago
  • bornofanatombomb
    bornofanatombomb reblogged this · 11 years ago
  • toxicfix
    toxicfix liked this · 11 years ago
  • smooshedrice
    smooshedrice liked this · 11 years ago
prasannachoudhary - Wandering Mind
Wandering Mind

'Naitaavad enaa, paro anyad asti' (There is not merely this, but a transcendent other). Rgveda. X, 31.8.

210 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags