ššcommitment right here, folks. I will be reading the docs just to firm up my characterization of JW for the fic Iām working on
Thereās been a ton of discourse surrounding the character of John Walker, everyone has a lot of opinions. But having read many articles, posts, tweets, and watched reaction channels and video essays, I have found a common theme among them: a fundamental misunderstanding of the character due to the story framing.
In fact, the character of John Walker that exists in fandom discussions is more of a projection of what peopleĀ thinkĀ he is and what peopleĀ wantĀ him to stand in for rather than the actual canonically established character that exists in the story of The Falcon and The Winter Soldier. This is why I have decided to write this post along with an episode-by-episode breakdown, because I think John Walker the character has been completely eclipsed by John Walker the symbol, lost underneath the iconography that heās been associated with and not really given a fair look as an individual person.
I should make it clear upfront; it is not my intention with this to tell people how they should feel about a character. Whether you agree with my points or not doesnāt really matter. My hope is that this at the very least provides you with a different perspective on the character and his motivations. Maybe have you consider him in a new way.
So, letās start from the beginning.
āāāāāāāāāāā
EPISODE 1
Story framing is important, it effects our perspective as an audience, and it is deliberately controlled by the writers and filmmakers to manipulate certain emotions and impressions out of us. The Falcon and The Winter Soldier expertly does this from the very beginning by framing John Walker immediately as someone whom we should not want.
Because the music is mournful and ominous despite the celebratory occasion shown on TV.
Because Sarah is upset.
Because Sam has his fists clenched and is unhappy and suspicious, and then closes his eyes in upset.
Because when dialogues like this is delivered, the show is purposefully playing into real life iconography and feelings that already raises our hackles.
Because Sam retired the shield and the hero position, so when someone else seemingly carelessly and casually steps in waving like a propaganda piece with a gun on his hip, and a grey flag symbol that looks so close to the thin blue line flag used by cops, there is something unsettling to us even if we didnāt consciously pick up on it, we just know that it goes against what we want and what our main protagonist wants.Ā
Because this strange person in a Cap costume winking looks like a jerk. We didnāt ask for this.Ā
As itās always said, first impressions are important. How someone first perceives you decides how someone might judge anything that you do. If someone thinks youāre an arrogant jerk, then anything you do will be colored by that impression and they will never think well of your intentions. But if their first impression of you is kind and caring, then any mistakes you made is automatically given leeway because your intentions would be well considered. And in one fell swoop, the show firmly planted into the minds of every single person watching that John Walker is an arrogant jerk espousing propaganda no one wants and everything he does is automatically suspect and questionable.Ā
In fact, they even go the extra step to make that very clear by how the cast credits is used. Notice the difference between the image of Walker in Episode 1 and Episode 2-6?
The red mark over his eyes, blocking him from us, not only feels foreboding, it feels as if itās warning us.Ā
So, when I say that John Walker was from the beginning set up to fail, itās because he was, the story intended for it to be. We have to hate, question, suspect, and think the worst of Walker in order for Samās eventual reclaiming of the shield to mean anything or have that emotional catharsis. Because nobody wants to see Sam take the shield from a nice dude, it would be bittersweet or even mean, but if the story tells us that this guy is someone we can dislike or hate right off the bat because there is something vaguelyĀ ābadā about him, then we would root for Sam to take that shield.
There is a reason we donāt get Walkerās perspective at all in his introduction. Heās just this stranger weāve been programmed as an audience to hate. We are not treated to Walker waiting to go outside and feeling nervous, or Walker doubting himself or perhaps even not wanting to take up the shield at first when it was given to him. The purposeful lack of his perspective is done so we only feel the weight of emotions from the Wilsons being upset, because we must relate to the protagonists.
Walker is not the hero of this story, heās not the protagonist of this story, if he was, then the story would have framed his unveiling as Captain America in a completely different way, and we would have been treated to a sympathetic look at what he was feeling about taking on the shield, we would have had an inside look at his mindset before he walked out there and looked into that camera and winked. But because we the audience lack that important context that was deliberately kept away from us, our views on Walker formed and solidified without it, and then we all stewed on those feelings for a whole week.Ā
By the time Episode 2 rolled around to open with Walkerās perspective, the damage was already done, it was too late, because people had already made up their mind about what kind of a person he was, and even those who might have given him a chance was just waiting for the other shoe to drop.Ā
The show had very clearly made sure that John Walker was always going to have an uphill battle in the eyes of the fans, however fairly or unfairly. And that deliberate and purposeful removal of his perspective and context would be the key to how the character will be misread. Because the reality is, Walker hasnāt even done anything wrong yet and people have already made assumptions just because of one wink, just because of his mere presence. There was no objective consideration that Walker winked because he understood having to put on a cheerful public facade, no consideration that he could have been told to play along nicely for the cameras and directed to look there and wink, no consideration that he didnāt ask for this job but was ordered to do so and is as much a āvictimā of the government as Sam. Because the show had already used every trick in the book to make us feel bad and ominous about his presence, the audience would automatically assume the worst.
Stay with me A little longer I will wait for you Shadows creep And want grows stronger Deeper than the truth
John stretches out the taut piece of fabric. Itās inlaid with kevlar (even a supersoldier goes down when they take a bullet), slightly thinner than usual for mobilityās sake. He turns to Zemo, raising an eyebrow. The man in question was tugging a pair of boots from the trunk where his uniform was.
āIt will do the job, but the bullet will still hurt.ā Zemo remarks. Often, when shot, the pain will not register fast enough. John had experienced it before. He would feel a blinding fire in his gut, and his feet would still be moving even when his body crumpled and folded under the hit. And lying there, in shock, he had thought- Iāve been shot. Iāve been shot. Over and over, blood spilling out of him, before it registered that heās been hit again by another bullet.Ā
āJust donāt freeze,ā Zemo reminds him again.
āItāll hurt just as much as being shot normally, just that the bullet wonāt penetrate. Youāre betting that I can handle the pain?ā John knows he could, but itās fun to rile Zemo up.
āYou will handle it.ā
āAnd if I come back with a shit ton of internal bleeding because of your negligence?ā
Before he knew it, Zemo was centimeters away from him, gloved hand digging viciously into a blackened bruise on his torse. John grits his teeth to prevent himself from making any sound. Zemo leans in, close enough that John could feel the heat of his breath and inhale the delicate scent of cherry blossom tea. āThen take it as your punishment, and donāt be so foolishly careless again.ā
Zemo takes a step back from him, fixes him with a searching gaze. John inhales slowly, recognising these moments as the eye of the storm, the silence and bated breath before thunder cracks the sky. He has learnt to treasure them. āAnd- I will not be negligent around you,ā Zemo says, voice catching in his throat. Then he says, a faint sterness in his voice that told John it was a reminder- āNot in anything I do.ā
The words what do you meanĀ are on the tip of his tongue, but John presses his lips into a tight line. He doesnāt want Zemo to spell out the obvious for him- attachment is negligence as well.
Zemo seems to be pleased by whatever minuscule reaction (or lack of) that he showed. The man nods to himself, satisfied, as he turns away and reaches for Johnās shield.
John puts on his suit with quick, practiced tugs. Then he buckles the buttons, alternating red and black, one by one in a slanted line down his chest; he squats down, yanking on his sleek combat boots. When he looks up, Zemo is observing him silently, head cocked to one side. John freezes, wondering if Zemo had been standing there the whole time, motionless, looking at his every movement. He reaches for his laces by the side table, but Zemoās hands find his.Ā
Oh. when had he taken off his gloves?
Wordlessly, Zemo lifts him from the floor. John could smell the leather still lingering on his bare fingers, and the softness of his touch, calloused only on the middle finger where a stylus rests. These are hands that hold heavy gold chalices and silver letter-openers, sharp as a knife. And they stamp royal carvings into hot wax, sealing letters that will decide the fates of millions.
Johnās blood turns molten all of a sudden, pumping hard and fast under his skin. He wanted to spill blood all over those dainty fingers, and knowing Zemo, it could be golden ichor. He imagined it crusted into fingernails, could nearly taste it hot on his tongue, war paint befitting of royalty.Ā
He lifts Zemoās hand, holding that wild gaze, and plants a chaste kiss on the back, chapped lips sliding against soft skin. āBaron,ā he says, reveling in the shaky inhale that he hears.
Zemoās eyes are wide, pupils dilated. His hand hovers over where Johnās heart is. After a few seconds Zemo retracts his hand as if burnt and glances away, with the expression that John has come to associate with cornered and run. But he does not take a step back, doesnāt even make up some bullshit excuse to run away.Ā
John knows that neither shock nor fear can make Zemo come to a standstill. So here, there is something inexplicably different that has pinned him to place like a dried butterfly to a corkboard.
āHold still.ā
He watches, mesmerised, as Zemo sinks to his knees and begins to lace up his boots, fingers working deftly to thread string through metal rings.
When the job is done, Zemo straightens again and looks at him square in the eyes. Fully clothed and ready for combat, something deeply calm has settled into John, reducing the world around him to a gentle hum. āUS Agent,ā Zemo says. HisĀ expression is not loving or warm, but his brows are furrowed in worry and John knows itās the closest thing to kindness heāll get.
āIām here,ā John says. It might have been a trick of the light, or his brain hallucinating some source of comfort, but he couldāve sworn there was a smile on Zemoās lips just then, for barely a second.
But walking away and out of the equipment room, he hears a softĀ good luck behind him, and knows thereās no doubt about it.
I can't help but love you Even though I try not to
I aspire to one day be as show-stopping and fearlessly revolutionary as Carpenter Brutās entire aesthetic.
Anyone interested in Lovecraft, Twilight Zone, Gods and Mythology should search up āFab Toolā.
The visuals there are the best Iāve seen all year.
Holy shit. Holy fudging shit. This is so good and poetic. WTF. Do you have golden fingers because this is amazing. WHAT THE ACTUAL HECK THIS IS SO GOOD? AHHHHHH??!?! Dude i- i just... i... THE WAY YOU USE WORDS IS AMAZING DUDE I WISH I COULD WRITE LIKE YOU
Last Rites. Zemo. Angst. His fate is inevitable; no matter where he goes, he is driven by loss.
Two roads diverge and in one moment, Zemo and the Baron split apart. Thereās Zemo on one side of the great divide, watching his whole world crumble around him. Thereās the Baron who said fuck the mission and took his family on holiday someplace far away and quiet; he hears the breeze sighing in the long grass and holds his wife just a little closer.
What couldāve been. What couldāve been. What couldāveā
Itās a sigh like a dying curse and Zemo hears it every moment of every day. It flavors his coffee and wraps around his ankles to bind him in his cell. It tells him listen, when she said she felt so scared, what did you say?
(Iāll be home soon)
But there is no home, not anymore, not since he stood on the threshold of the end of ā not the world but his worldā and saw the ruin of everything. What is a man without a country? What is a man who smiles despite the knife in his gut?
The Baron watches the seasons change across the wasteland and he sees his son grow up. He says all of this is yours, every stone and every blade of grass. He hears about the cityās fall and is somehow unsurprised; Avengers are synonymous with ruin, with trails of destruction left behind while they retreat to their tower and lick their wounds. The Baron says all this is yours, every smear of blood and every shadow; when I dieā not if, but whenā donāt follow. Build a better world. He saysā he saysā but all his words are wasted.
Our father, who art the source of malice, gathers every thread and pulls us close. We pray the devils take us, for they at least are honest; they at least have made no promises.
And here comes Zemo with a face like a summer storm, wild and torn by thunder, all his ghosts around him like a mantle and if he smiles itās only because he senses his nearness to the other side. He walks like a man who has nothing to lose because he doesnāt ā his heart is gone, all the bones of his dear ones buried in the earth far from home because the family crypt was crushed and all its many sleeping dead thrown about like so much straw. Here comes Zemo with his gloves and his coat and even if he hides his face his eyes are still there, dark and piercing, every blink an indictment and every tear a curse.
Here comes Zemo, the trinity of ghosts: father, son and spouse; he sees the other side and doesnāt wonder why couldnāt it be that way because there is no time; he sets his plans in motion and shepherds them to the outcome he wants (the outcome he needs; he has the grief of love, of lovers, of someone whoās only ever known violence as a tool, who doesnāt fear death or pain but only the shards of his shattered heart that pierce through him)
Our father, who shows us the back of his hand, who curdles our milk and picks the lashes from our eyelids, our father, who shows us a door thatās locked and barredā
The Baron sees his people scattered, broken; he traces the threads of their dissolution back to the source, which is the Tower; he hears their cries for mercy and for aid and somehow, somehow, he is the last of their royalty, the last one with enough pull to do something (enough money squirreled away, at least, and the implacable cruelty needed to show no mercy). He says Iāll be home soon and goes to carry out his duty. If I let it go, if I let it go,
(Weāll be together)
We will never know peace. We will never know the satisfaction of looking at the stars without wondering who will descend to tear us apart.
When the Baron returns with blood on his hands (how they fought, but cleverness and tech and all the money in the world are no match for the calculated rage of a man who kills to protect, who will ruin angels to tear their prying eyes from those he loves)ā when the Baron returnsā
(Iām home)
āitās to a quiet house and blood on the walls; the last of those he loved now dying on the floor and thereās a message. Thereās always a message. You couldnāt protect us. So many dead, and when we looked to you, youād fled. And then you left to chase your dragons, but the wolves slipped through your door. The Baron doesnāt cry. He canāt cry. He buries his dead and closes up his country house; he will find those responsible and share his suffering.
Our father, who maketh us to lie in green fields, who draws the stars down to drive them through our flesh. Our father, who pulls fateās threads and cuts them free. Our father, king of filth and decadence.
Zemo lets his beard grow and thinks about what could have been. Itās a petty, weak indulgence and it makes him ache; it makes his hands twitch with the need to hold a gun again, to act, to move. He reads, he listens to the radio, he waits. He pushes the sleeves of his hoodie up and leans against the bars.
Zemo has a visitor. He sees his way out and he smiles his crooked smile.
Our father.
I suddenly just did a double take and reconsidered my life choices. Why do I even ship John walker and Zemo? Theyāve only interacted once, and here I am thinking theyād be perfectly, perversely compatible, enough to write a fic about it.
What the fuck-
Actually, this reminds me of something my sis once told me:
āYou ship a bad person with another bad person because then they can hurt each other.ā
And I think thatās so true for this case. I mean, mutually assured destruction is pretty hot, amirite? I think John would pretty much wreck Zemo (and in more ways than one š), make him question everything heās ever known about his own morals and ideals. And Zemo would of course return that favour twofold. The push and pull between them would really be interesting, truly an unstoppable force meets immovable object.
Plus, thereās a heavy dose of sin there as well. John has a wife (oh sweet jesus no), Zemo had a wife, and it would be amusing to see them try and justify their own attraction towards each other.
Then thereās the concept of moving on, avenging, both of them trying to find their own goals in life and realizing that their paths inexplicably cross along the way.
If I ever do get my fic out one day I hope itās a gateway drug for future WalkerBaron shippers...
Also my blog might turn nsfw real quick real soon š„“cos oooooooh baby you know Iām like a man slugging thru the desert and daniel is my fountain
If in Thunderbolts, Zemo and Walker team up (WalkerBaron), Iām headcanonising:
- Walker calling Zemo a ālil bitchā on the daily
- Walker raising his shield to protect the both of them from falling debris and Zemo just standing under the shade in mild wonder
- Zemo bitch slapping Walker
- Walker pours Zemoās finest wine into a cut to ādisinfectā it, Zemo letting out an unholy screech, and downing the entire bottle in response
- Zemo bitch slapping Walker again
- Walker trying to undermine Zemoās authority by looming over him, Zemo responds by purposely walking in front of him and suddenly stopping just to make John crash into him
- Zemo calling Walker āAgentā instead of āUS Agentā out of spite
- Zemo sidestepping Johnās advances like siiiiiike we gotta be pRoFfEsSiOnAl
Then later justifying their relationship by saying āItās a mutually beneficial exchange.ā
- Zemo always trying to discreetly keep John in his peripheral vision, because that man was his temporary protection and lifeline
Bonus:
Zemo tries to guide Walker down a bad path to justify killing him eventually. Walker takes the bait. But little does Zemo know, the man drags Zemo down alongside him, topples Zemoās little moral pedestal right into the depths of depravity.
Now thatās a relationship Iād love to explore.
Iāve been waiting for someone to say this for a long ass time
When Daniel Brühl's hair does that thing where one slightly curly bang falls out of place and on his forehead reblog if you agree
A little oneshot I thought about while writing Zemo- Iāve decided to put it here.
Zemo tells an audience of children all about Sokovia, how the earth there was rich and matted, and all around them tall grass would spin out crackling sounds.
That if you walk far enough into the rising mountains, till you could only see the tops of the low terrace houses and the smoke spiraling up lazily from your house chimney, and you closed your eyes: youād hear the rise and fall of hissing grass, theyād turn in huge ocean waves as the wind blew.
He would name all the mountain ridges, from the snowy peaks, all the way to the parts where the ice melted and trickled down into streams, gathering into cold rivers and bubbling springs. The water would be a pale green from afar, and a hazy yellow up close, reflecting the small brown rocks that lined the bottom.
Heād tell them that where the river mouth was, the water was flowing clear and crisp, and children used to drink from it and catch tadpoles. A kilometer down, where the bustle of the town was, the river would be sun-warmed and algae infested, swirling lazily around and releasing the deep grassy perfume of the hills, saturating the air. In summer this was even more so.
When the plum and apple trees were ripe you could pick the fruits as they came bobbing down the river. The children would stand at the banks and fish them out with long nets, and even those that were partially rotten would be taken back home.
When the sun rose you could hear the song of the Stieglitz- the goldfinches, all across the valley. And the Gimplel with their red bellies and the Blaumeise, the rotund little scoundrels with their small beaks.
Thereād be roads of crunching gravel and houses built on hills, stacked up like a mound of uneven books, the steps and rooftops cascading down into flatland where the bridge crosses the river and meets land.
You could harvest berries from the mountains, any berry was the right one, all were ripe and burst into sugary water in your mouth. You could pluck them straight from the stems, collect bunches and bunches, eating and spitting out the seeds as you went.
When the apple flowers bloomed he would wear crowns of them in his hair, spun by the maids that worked for his mother and father. They smelt delicate and sweet, like roses but without the dampness, and just a hint of fresh apple skins. When he was young he had thought they were cherry blossoms, for they looked so much alike. And he would tell the children in a conspiratorial whisper, that these were better than cherry blossoms, for they flourished for months and months instead of a mere week.
And then the children, in wonder and amazement, would tug at his sleeves, asking him to point out his country on the map. Zemoās gaze would drift away, his face would settle into the mould of its suffering... Sokovia was gone from the maps, would only exist in his memory.
Slowly, the children would see that he was drifting away, they would lose interest and run away to play together, leaving him alone with his thoughts.
Sitting alone, Zemo thinks of fires burning and towns flying, snow melting under tremendous heat. He remembers water evaporating, berries and flowers crushed under stampeding feet, and the smell of smoke. The grass is no more, the roads and the rooftops are no more, theyāve been covered by wet concrete.
Amazing work!
6000ė ė§ģ ė©ģ“ģ ģ”ģģ¼ėź¹ ć ć“ ģ³ėØ¹źø°ė§ķ ź³ķ
Lmao I was laughing nervously in the theatre because I was like- guys, that was a CHOICE šš
I saw someone pointing this out....(sorry I didn't know who you are anymore if you saw this please notify me) this must be part of Simu Liu's fault too because he literally can't take his eyes off of Tony Leung on set he was so star struck š¤£. Simu HE is your dad in the movie please.