Thingol, Luthien, And Dior’s Claim To The Silmaril Bugs The Living Daylights Outta Me And I’m Gonna

Thingol, Luthien, and Dior’s claim to the silmaril bugs the living daylights outta me and I’m gonna break down why. This goes a bit beyond ownership laws.

Starting with basics. What are the silmarils? Gems created by Fëanor that hold the light of the Two Trees. Who in Beleriand saw the light of the trees and no doubt misses it like a limb? Are here in part to avenge their destruction? The Noldor.

The Sindar never went to Valinor. They might find the gems beautiful but that’s it. There’s no cultural or emotional connection to them beyond ‘pretty stone, look how awesome our princess was.’ There’s no appreciation for what they hold. No understanding that this stone is one of the *last* things that holds the ancient light of the Trees.

The Noldor meanwhile not only saw the Light, they had entire festivals surrounding it. Grew their entire culture, their lives, under and around it. Now the trees are destroyed, their king killed defending these jewels. And this last beacon of hope, a piece of the home they can never return to, a piece of light that will never come back, is being kept by people who can’t even begin to understand the significance of what they keep.

Now imagine being the sons of the one who made this jewel from a culture of people who value craft above all else.

Not only is it light, it’s the result of years of toil and experimentation of your father, the one who managed to do what no one had ever even thought of. Fëanor’s sons would have been the first to see these jewels, probably saw him make prototypes, work equations whilst they worked on their own crafts. Provided what relief they could to his ever working mind and inadvertently gave him ideas that helped solve problems he encountered along the way. Suddenly it’s not only a key part of their culture, it’s something core to their family.

Then Fëanor is killed and in many ways it’s the most important thing they have left of their father. Now it’s a source of memory too, for someone doomed to the Halls for eternity. Who they’ll likely never see again unless they’re killed.

Now from what I’ve heard, Tolkien says the Fëanorions lost their right to the Silmarils when they killed for them. Which makes no sense considering the Silmarils were *created* by Fëanor. Yes the light was created by the Valar, but what, you’re gonna say ‘I created electricity so that lightbulb you made is actually mine.’ That’s not how it works. Fëanor made the casing for the stones and figured out how to hold the light, without aid from the Valar. It doesn’t matter what actions they take, the right to the Silmarils remain theirs and theirs alone. The jewels hold no power of their own, they’re literally objects. Healing objects at most. Morals do not dictate their ownership, hallowed or not.

Tolkien going on to say the right of Doriath’s Silmaril actually goes to Beren and Luthien for taking it from Morgoth gives me frankly coloniser vibes.

‘Oh this thing I stole was originally stolen from you? Too bad. I took it so it’s mine now. Don’t care how important it is to you, your entire culture, and your people.’

Get where I’m coming from?

All in all the whole situation gives me Bad Vibes and I really don’t like the attitude the Sindar have to the Silmaril. In terms of Elwing, I can partly forgive her purely based on trauma response. Fine. Doesn’t make it right, but I understand. But that never would’ve been a problem if her father, grandmother, or great grandfather had the sense to acknowledge the silmaril was never theirs to keep. Don’t like the Fëanorions, (too bad) at least give it back to the Noldor.

More Posts from Elthbe and Others

2 months ago
Eowyn & Faramir

Eowyn & Faramir

mixed media, 53*35 cm

1 month ago
elthbe - Senza titolo
elthbe - Senza titolo

Best uncle 🌟🌟

(the age here are probably not canon but hey, i'm free 🫡)

3 months ago
Here’s A Sketch Of Maedhros From My Work-in-progress Fanfic About The Ambarussar Starting A Religion.

Here’s a sketch of Maedhros from my work-in-progress fanfic about the Ambarussar starting a religion. Mae hasn’t heard from the twins in years, so he goes to check on them. He soon starts to feel severely overdressed when he arrives at the twins’ isolated ascetic cult community where everyone wears the same brown tunic (he has zero clue what he’s walking into.)

I aim to draw the twins next but alas they will be less sexy since they are quite emaciated, especially Amrod

A5 paper, markers, took about three hours

4 months ago

every day I think about how insane Tolkien was for having Aegnor, Fell Fire, Sharp-flame, the flame to Andreth's moth, die during the Battle of Sudden Flame

5 months ago

Between the curse of Mandos that loomed over every exile and Turin's own doom Beleg never stood a fucking chance. Gwindor and Turin meet for the first time and the force of their collective inability to keep a love one alive was so strong poor Beleg immediately exited the narrative

3 weeks ago
Idril Meeting Tuor For The First Time XD

Idril meeting Tuor for the first time xD

Idril Meeting Tuor For The First Time XD

Idril is having a full shoujo manga experience, while Tuor is trying to navigate a political drama loll

7 months ago
Maglor And Galadriel

Maglor and Galadriel

join my community on telegram

https://t.me/tari_kuaept

I come here more often and draw special pictures just for the channel

2 months ago

I was thinking of Beren and Lúthien and how their story is so much more interesting than they get credit for. I mean, on the surface it reads like a fairy tale but it also elevates the rest of the story, it uses common fairy tale tropes but turns them upside down, and the way we see the heroine asserting her agency in this story is so fascinating. I think the story of Beren and Lúthien provides much needed contrast for the rest of the Silm, and both become more poignant because of this contrast. 

The familiar fairy tale goes like this: there's a a poor but resourceful peasant, set with a difficult task (which is in fact designed to be impossible to complete), but thanks to some magical help he is successful, retrieves treasure, and as a reward he wins the king's daughter and lives happily ever after as a prince, gaining all the earthly glory one can have in this life. But in the Tale of Beren and Lúthien, the hero is a traumatised outlaw, the king's daughter IS the magical help, she is an active and equal participant in the quest for her own hand in marriage, the treasure may actually be cursed, the hero and heroine die, and the ultimate reward is not a social rise from rags to riches. Beren does not become a member of the power-wielding elite of Doriath and he and Lúthien are not promised that their second life will be happy or long. But just that chance is worth it, and by choosing it they actually change the course of history. Lúthien is offered all the bliss that is possible to have in Arda, if she will give up Beren, but she decides that the love she has for him is still more valuable. And that idea, of loving someone so much that your love shifts the world, is so compelling to me. 

And I love that the story of Beren and Lúthien is also a rendition of Orpheus and Eurydice, and that just as the world was created in the Music of the Ainur, so is Lúthien's song powerful enough to change what those original notes dictated. She changes it with hope and a song. That is so simple and yet so beautiful, in the way some of the best myths are. (Insane that this is essentially a love-letter to Edith Tolkien.)

There is this fascinating contrast between Beren and Lúthien: at the time of their first meeting, Beren has lost literally everything and his family is either dead or lost beyond retrieval. Stumbling across Lúthien, he is fresh from terrible ordeals and suffering. But Lúthien's life has been full of happiness and without care, and she has lived in a literal fairy kingdom as the most beautiful of all the Children of Ilúvatar. She could have her pick of any prince of Eldar. But here she comes across this mortal, who has nothing to give except for his love and even that only for a brief time, and she is willing to risk all she has for it. The gall and courage it takes to take such a chance! She chooses this man and her choice changes everything. 

And that is brilliant! Because Lúthien starts with so little power and agency, and she is constantly belittled or even abused by those with more power around her. She is treated as a pawn, her will is undermined and she is coerced and imprisoned to make her compliant. But Lúthien shows her determination and courage in holding fast to her choice even when it's just her and Beren against the world. In the end, she wins agency and freedom to determine her own tale. In her beginning Lúthien is a maid dancing in the woods; by the end she will have faced Satan and death itself, and changed the world forever. Truly, to call her story "Release from Bondage" is more than appropriate. How insane is this all from Beren's point of view? He has lost everything, he is an outlaw, and has nowhere to go. What is left of his family is scattered who knows where. He has nothing but the clothes on his back and nothing to give. But here is this immortal princess, and she will go to hell and back with him! She will cross the Sundering Sea to bid him farewell! She pleads with inexorable death and for her, an exception is made!  It's so on brand for Tolkien that these two achieve with their love, and precisely because they act out of love, something that others with armies behind their backs can't even imagine doing.

Yeah. It's such a good, hopeful, bittersweet tale.

4 months ago

Galadriel's Song of Eldamar

I sang of leaves, of leaves of gold, and leaves of gold there grew:

Of wind I sang, a wind there came and in the branches blew.

Beyond the Sun, beyond the Moon, the foam was on the Sea,

And by the strand of Ilmarin there grew a golden Tree.

Beneath the stars of Ever-eve in Eldamar it shone,

In Eldamar beside the walls of Elven Tirion.

There long the golden leaves have grown upon the branching years,

While here beyond the Sundering Seas now fall the Elven-tears.

O Lórien! The Winter comes, the bare and leafless Day;

The leaves are falling in the stream, the river flows away.

O Lórien! Too long I have dwelt upon this Hither Shore

And in a fading crown have twined the golden elanor.

But if of ships I now should sing, what ship would come to me,

What ship would bear me ever back across so wide a Sea?

-- J.R.R. Tolkien, The Fellowship of the Ring --

.

1 month ago

wish gimli was real so i could hangout with him. need a chill guy like that in my life

  • blighted-slyph
    blighted-slyph liked this · 1 week ago
  • harleynottquinn
    harleynottquinn liked this · 1 week ago
  • misssamire
    misssamire liked this · 1 week ago
  • brittklein18
    brittklein18 liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • tolkienlover15
    tolkienlover15 liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • idontdodrugsiamdrugsx
    idontdodrugsiamdrugsx liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • thelovelychaos
    thelovelychaos liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • virtual-dragon-almond-bakery
    virtual-dragon-almond-bakery reblogged this · 2 weeks ago
  • privetitsme
    privetitsme liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • mal3f1cent
    mal3f1cent reblogged this · 2 weeks ago
  • khaleesi-elrond
    khaleesi-elrond liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • nelyosmissinghand
    nelyosmissinghand reblogged this · 2 weeks ago
  • nelyosmissinghand
    nelyosmissinghand liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • 49octopi
    49octopi liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • inthehouseoffinwe
    inthehouseoffinwe reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • inthehouseoffinwe
    inthehouseoffinwe reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • auroramama
    auroramama reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • auroramama
    auroramama reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • im-not-a-ghost-i-swear
    im-not-a-ghost-i-swear liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • shiningroyalty
    shiningroyalty liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • q-zida
    q-zida liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • inthehouseoffinwe
    inthehouseoffinwe reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • tamest4991
    tamest4991 reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • inthehouseoffinwe
    inthehouseoffinwe reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • tamest4991
    tamest4991 reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • make-eva
    make-eva reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • make-eva
    make-eva liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • princessamarifei
    princessamarifei liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • punkrock-furiosa
    punkrock-furiosa liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • itsajokeuknow
    itsajokeuknow liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • roma360
    roma360 liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • multifandom-landfill-site
    multifandom-landfill-site liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • hallas-laucahrive
    hallas-laucahrive liked this · 1 month ago
  • fadingfireperson
    fadingfireperson reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • fadingfireperson
    fadingfireperson liked this · 1 month ago
  • ginkgo-daydream
    ginkgo-daydream liked this · 1 month ago
  • oldgermanthehunter
    oldgermanthehunter reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • oldgermanthehunter
    oldgermanthehunter reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • money-and-dandellions
    money-and-dandellions liked this · 1 month ago
  • maglorbby
    maglorbby liked this · 1 month ago
  • warmteainrain
    warmteainrain liked this · 1 month ago
  • edgyteenager01
    edgyteenager01 liked this · 1 month ago
  • freshmagazineobject
    freshmagazineobject liked this · 1 month ago
  • esmeraude11
    esmeraude11 liked this · 1 month ago
  • gaygothdancemachine
    gaygothdancemachine liked this · 1 month ago
  • multifandomfan253
    multifandomfan253 liked this · 1 month ago
elthbe - Senza titolo
Senza titolo

112 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags