Collapsecomplex - Kaaaaaaaaaaaaaru

Snake (スネーク) - Kuroshitsuji: Midori no Majo-hen - Episode 1

giving “unsolicited criticism” on someone’s fanfic doesn’t make you cool and your “suggestion” is definitely not helping the author lol

what fanfic is is 1.) free, 2.) something an artist writes for fun, 3.) their source of comfort and joy.

unless specifically asked, fanfic writers are not looking forward to hearing your unsolicited criticism, even if you do so “politely”. by reading someone’s fic, you ask the author to let you in their house and they let you in. if you end up not liking their place, you quietly leave. you don’t start telling them things you don’t like about their house.

“but I was being polite when I tell them their bed should be bigger” “I was saying it so nicely when I let them know pink did not suit their couch” no. you’re not helping. you’re just telling them they should adjust their place in order to fit your personal liking. it’s their house. not yours. build your own house instead of telling strangers how their houses should be.

if authors didn’t ask for your opinions and if you don’t have anything nice to say, be quiet.

yknow im slightly surprised people don't have more thoughts about sekais from a system lens. maybe bc the entire unit made/has access to it so it feels less ""personal"" or wtv subconscious reason but like. pov you just went through a traumatizing experience and have no idea where to go from here and then one day a fictive of your idol shows up like Hiii come to our manifestation of your own hopes and dreams and maybe i can make you feel a lil better :)" and it works and now you just know your very own personal hatsune miku you can talk to and hang out with whenever.

and the sekai starts out simple with just miku and one or two other people but as your life goes on and you progress with your dreams and stepping stones get in your way the sekai grows and more people climb out of the woodwork from nowhere introduce themselves and help wherever they can

idk it feels like something can be made with this

Dear video essay creators. A video analysis is when you analyze a piece of media. No no look at me. A summary, no matter how thorough, is not an analysis. An analysis requires you to draw conclusions about the media such as authorial intent, real-world parallels, discussion about themes/worldbuilding/character motivation, and so much more. You have to stop summarizing something and saying that’s analysis. The Gaylors are doing more critical analysis than you. Is that who you want to lose to? The gaylors?

the kagamines

u...u wa wa u wa.......

Snake (スネーク) - Kuroshitsuji: Midori no Majo-hen - Episode 5

My average writing experience:

"Alright I think I'm almost done actually-"

*Google doc grows second health bar and a choir starts singing in latin*

Illustration by Colorful Palette staff

agreed, fans should not be afraid to interact with the author of a fic they like because in the end we all like that thing and its what brings us together, lol

plus, as an author, comments and kudos give me motivation and fuel me to write. a lot of the times i do talk about fics to other people, but i do kudos all the fics i like

i dont get why people are so afraid to show their appreciation to an author when in the end we’re all loser enough to write and read about fictional characters. plus, kudos exists for a reason, and even if youre too scared to kudos something on your account, you could do it on a guest or something idk

i definitely agree with this entirely btw

So recently I've noticed a lot of discussion in fandom spaces regarding how readers discuss fics in private Discord servers without the author present, and as a fanfic writer myself, I'm... kind of conflicted.

On one hand, I believe that readers have the right to a space away from the author where they can freely share their thoughts on the fic with one another, especially when those thoughts are not 100% positive nor otherwise appropriate to share with the author directly. Discussing a fic with your friends is a very different social situation to leaving a comment directly on the fic where you'd expect the author to see it, so I can understand why some readers choose to do one but not the other, especially since many authors don't want any constructive criticism nor anything perceived as negative in their fic comments. I will admit, I do sometimes wonder if, or how often, people talk about my writing in private spaces, but it's only an idle curiosity, not a thought that keeps me up at night.

On the other hand, if a bunch of people talk about a particular fanfic in a private server, but none of them comment on the fic directly, or worse, leave kudos, then that's kind of weird, IMO. I've read anecdotes from fellow writers detailing how they got little to no feedback on their fic and thought nobody was reading it, only to discover that a bunch of people were reading it, but only sharing their thoughts in a private space the author wasn't privy to. That's fucked up. Fanfiction authors should not be seen as above their readers, even if their fics are on Heat Waves levels of notoriety. We're fans just like you, and we'd love to have the opportunity to discuss our work with fellow fans. If our work means so much to you that you stay up all night reading it, that you can't stop thinking about it, that you're driven to gush about it with your friends – we want to hear about it! If you're going to talk about a fic in a private space, the very least you could do is leave kudos, just to let the author know that yes, someone is out there reading and enjoying their stuff. Again, readers have the right to that private space, and to be honest I personally don't mind if they don't also comment directly on my fics; that's absolutely fine, I consider comments to be a lovely bonus rather than an expectation. But I know how hurtful and isolating it can be to think that nobody even cares enough to say "thank you, I liked this!" in response to a piece of writing you've poured your heart and soul into.

Idk, that's just my two cents on the matter.