Get Back Narrative

Get Back Narrative

I’ve received a couple of asks seeking clarification regarding my earlier post about how the Get Back documentary was redefining the Beatle narrative.

I’ll try to summarize. 

1. Media articles like this, this and this regarding Ono’s presence. While it’s obvious that the band was heading toward dissolution with or without Ono’s presence, Ono’s continued presence in the studio, her unsolicited participation in band business (no, she didn’t just sit there and read, as some would claim), and her willingness to speak on John’s behalf is hardly exculpatory. Even Time magazine, which at least attempted a more considered analysis of the Beatle break-up era, claimed, after watching Get Back, that ‘Yoko’s presence was not a huge negative factor, and that none of the band members appear much bothered by her constant presence; they joke and talk with her comfortably”.  This is a shocking claim, given that a) the documentary clearly depicts the deleterious effect of Yoko’s presence upon band members during the failed meeting at George’s house, and b) George, Paul, and Ringo have all gone on record regarding their discomfort in Ono’s presence and the disruptive nature of her involvement in band business. 

(As an aside, I would also like to know in what workplace, no matter how creative or unorthodox, it would be acceptable to bring your lover or spouse to work everyday and insist that the presence of that person was absolutely benign.)  

2. The exclusion of information which would provide context to behaviour, such as John and Yoko’s heroin addiction. “By the advent of the “Get Back” sessions, Ono openly joked about taking heroin being the couple’s form of exercise”).  This was excluded in the Get Back documentary and, as a consequence, from mainstream media. Obviously the inclusion of this information would more accurately contexualize John’s behaviour in the band, including his insistence on Yoko’s presence.  

Another compelling piece of information that was not included in the documentary was that Patti Harrison briefly left George around the time of George’s departure from the band.  Since there was no mention of this event during filming, Peter Jackson decided not to share it, claiming he didn’t want to make any “moral judgements.” To whatever extent his brief estrangement from Patti affected George’s judgement we’ll never know (George didn’t even mention it in his diary of that day), but its exclusion in the documentary is regrettable. 

3.  Editorial Choices by the filmmaker.  Peter Jackson has gone on record that he was not influenced by Ringo or Paul, and nor by Olivia or Yoko at any point in the making of the Get Back Documentary. And there’s no reason not to believe him.  But:  the Get Back documentary reflects his editorial choices–what he believed was important to leave in, and what he believed was acceptable to leave out.  As Erin Torkelson Weber indicated in this earlier post, “the reality is that, without unrestricted access to the hundreds of hours of actual audio and visual tapes Hogg and Jackson used to make their films, fans are still being offered only someone else’s interpretation/vision/translation of the primary source material…so we have to rely on evidence that has already been framed and filtered.” 

And that reality–that we are watching someone’s else’s version of the truth, has escaped mainstream media and a certain cohort of Beatle fans who either find the Get Back version of the Beatle break-up era more commensurate with their own beliefs, or simply don’t know any better. 

More Posts from Chetthedog1904 and Others

2 years ago
archiveofourown.org
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works

I rewrote an old fic cause before I was presenting Ringo as straight and I'm tired of doing that.

Pretty proud of this.

Lots of McStarr but most other ships are mentioned too.

I Rewrote An Old Fic Cause Before I Was Presenting Ringo As Straight And I'm Tired Of Doing That.

it's inspired by this photo

2 years ago

Gorgeous

PAUL MCCARTNEY Being Interviewed After The Beatles Received Their MBEs From The Queen; October 26th,
PAUL MCCARTNEY Being Interviewed After The Beatles Received Their MBEs From The Queen; October 26th,
PAUL MCCARTNEY Being Interviewed After The Beatles Received Their MBEs From The Queen; October 26th,
PAUL MCCARTNEY Being Interviewed After The Beatles Received Their MBEs From The Queen; October 26th,

PAUL MCCARTNEY being interviewed after the Beatles received their MBEs from the Queen; October 26th, 1965.

2 years ago
Based On “Love Me Do: The Beatles’ Progress” By Michael Braun For The Observer (5 July 1964).

Based on “Love Me Do: The Beatles’ Progress” by Michael Braun for The Observer (5 July 1964).

Scotch and music:

“Uh, I need another drink, baby,’ says John.

Paul goes to the phone. ‘Hello? Yeah, send us six single Scotches - No, make it doubles, yeah, doubles.”

2 years ago

“John Lennon was in a movie theater, crying. The image of Paul, singing from the rooftop in the final 10 minutes, had set him off. Jann Wenner shifted in his seat. In the darkness of a tiny movie house in San Francisco, the Beatle, Wenner’s hero, whose iconic spectacles and nose adorned the first issue of his rock ‘n’ roll newspaper, Rolling Stone, had tears running down his cheeks as light flickered off his glasses. And next to him was Yoko Ono, the bête noire of Beatledom, raven hair shrouding her porcelain face, also weeping. It was a Saturday afternoon in the spring of 1970, and John and Yoko and Jann and his wife, Jane Wenner, were watching the final scenes of Let It Be, the documentary about the Beatles’ acrimonious recording session for their last album. John and Yoko were deep into primal-scream therapy, their emotions raw and close to the surface, and the image of a bearded Paul McCartney singing from the rooftop of Apple Records, against a cold London wind, was too much to bear. For Wenner, the 24-year-old boy wonder of the new rock press, who worshipped the Beatles as passionately as any kid in America, this was a dream, sitting here in the dark, wiping away his own tears at the twilight of the greatest band of all time, elbow-to-elbow with “the most famous person in the world, for God’s sake. And it’s just the four of us in the center of an empty theater,” marveled Wenner, “all kind of huddled together, and John is crying his eyes out.””

— Joe Hagan (biographer), Vanity Fair: Jann Wenner, John Lennon, and the Greatest Rolling Stone Cover Ever. (September 29th, 2017)


Tags
2 years ago

This is so perfect!

Welcome to the McLennon Multiverse


Tags
2 years ago

This is really good information

Getting Arrested 101

In light of yesterdays ruling on the Miranda rights, now that the cops don't need to read you your rights, I figure it's as good a time as any to make a crash course post on what to do if you get arrested in the US. Know your rights and how to invoke them, because cops will try and trick you into reneging on them whenever they can. Here's my bible on engaging with police, and feel free to add on if you have other tips.

If you encounter police at all, especially if it's for a protest, engage as little as possible. Protests will sometimes have police liaisons; if they do, deflect the cops onto them. They have training for this. Otherwise, say nothing to them if they don't engage first.

If they engage first, do not escalate. Cops are trained to try and escalate situations. It wins them PR, and it makes it easier for them to justify violence against you and in turn, the other protestors. I don't care how punk you think it is, do not escalate.

When they engage, if you think you're being arrested, ask them in no uncertain terms and demand a clear answer. Say "am I being arrested," and if they evade, repeat it until the answer is no or yes. If it's no, walk away and don't engage further. If it's yes, then:

Shut the fuck up. Say absolutely nothing from this point forward until you reach the station. No matter what they say, no matter how serious or casual the conversation is, you say nothing. Zip. No exceptions. This is especially important to remember because they will try and humiliate you and make the arrest process as difficult as possible to try and make you crack, so do the simplest thing and say nothing.

If you are arrested, once you make it to the station, there's a simple three step process to remember. Exact wording isn't necessary, but try and be close. Remember, you don't want to be Lawyer Dogged. Once again, be as clear as you possibly can.

"Am I being detained?" If no, leave. If yes, then say:

"I invoke my right to have a lawyer present." Any time they try and push on that, you say:

"As I am detained, I invoke my right to remain silent until my lawyer is present."

You want it to be 100% undeniable, in as much of the record as possible, that you were being detained, and therefor you need a lawyer. Otherwise, the cops will retroactively decide you weren't actually held there, and therefor you had no rights to invoke, so get that shit down. And once again, aside from saying #3, shut the fuck up. Same principle applies as #4 on the first list: they will do whatever they can to get you talking, and once they do, they'll say "oh, they decided to not use the lawyer after all because they started talking without one." So do. Not. Budge.

Lastly, some general pieces of advice, both for before and during the arrest process:

If you're going to a protest, the sort of thing where arrests can be planned for, there will likely be an organizer with some experience. They may be able to give you specific advice for that protest with regards to things like ID, liaisons, or any specific protocol. Check with them as well.

If you're in a situation where arrests are likely or expected, especially with a protest, plan accordingly. Power off your phone and deactivate the fingerprint or facial recognition unlock options, or leave it at home entirely. Don't bring anything you wouldn't want to be arrested with. Think carefully about leaving your ID at home, though. John Doe-ing can cause extra trouble for the cops (good), but it's also risky, since it can make it harder for you to pay for bail and can make things harder for you down the line.

Police always lie. Let me repeat. Police. Always. Lie. Again, Police. Always. Lie. This should be your fucking mantra. They will tell you you'll get out easier if you cooperate. They will tell you any information they can find about your friends and family. They will threaten you and them. This is all hollow. Your friends have rights as well. All of this is posturing to get you to talk and incriminate you and your friends. Police always lie.

Every American should know this, but it's especially important for any activist, or advocate. Knowing your rights is the only defense you have against cops, so you need to game that system to keep them from gaming it back.

2 years ago

🎉 1 MORE DAY UNTIL MCLENNON WEEK! 🎉

🎉 1 MORE DAY UNTIL MCLENNON WEEK! 🎉

Friendly reminder that McLennon Week begins tomorrow Monday July 4th!

(For more info check the guidelines and the prompt list posts.)


Tags
2 years ago
Some Pictures Of The Beatles With Each Others’ Children
Some Pictures Of The Beatles With Each Others’ Children
Some Pictures Of The Beatles With Each Others’ Children
Some Pictures Of The Beatles With Each Others’ Children
Some Pictures Of The Beatles With Each Others’ Children
Some Pictures Of The Beatles With Each Others’ Children

Some pictures of the Beatles with each others’ children

Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • irida-eleison
    irida-eleison liked this · 1 month ago
  • stinkyfartgirl
    stinkyfartgirl liked this · 10 months ago
  • lonainfield
    lonainfield reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • destrokkit
    destrokkit liked this · 10 months ago
  • tavolgisvist
    tavolgisvist liked this · 10 months ago
  • known-prequel-apologist
    known-prequel-apologist liked this · 10 months ago
  • paulandjohn
    paulandjohn reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • onlyexistingfootage
    onlyexistingfootage liked this · 10 months ago
  • herethereandeverywherewithbugs
    herethereandeverywherewithbugs reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • besohappilylarry
    besohappilylarry liked this · 10 months ago
  • packyourromanticmind
    packyourromanticmind liked this · 10 months ago
  • mallowedheart
    mallowedheart liked this · 10 months ago
  • floerpie
    floerpie liked this · 10 months ago
  • starrymajor
    starrymajor liked this · 10 months ago
  • woodenwound
    woodenwound liked this · 10 months ago
  • munhuip
    munhuip liked this · 10 months ago
  • tweeterwilbury
    tweeterwilbury liked this · 10 months ago
  • pushtlittledaisies
    pushtlittledaisies liked this · 10 months ago
  • georgeharrisonsmiling
    georgeharrisonsmiling reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • faulmccartney
    faulmccartney liked this · 10 months ago
  • good-to-drive
    good-to-drive reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • good-to-drive
    good-to-drive liked this · 10 months ago
  • get-back-homeward
    get-back-homeward reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • catladyjllll
    catladyjllll liked this · 1 year ago
  • strwberryflds
    strwberryflds liked this · 1 year ago
  • chetthedog1904
    chetthedog1904 reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • chetthedog1904
    chetthedog1904 liked this · 2 years ago
  • the-60s
    the-60s reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • lucy-2001
    lucy-2001 liked this · 2 years ago
  • the-60s
    the-60s reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • jls-kat
    jls-kat reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • numberninedream
    numberninedream liked this · 3 years ago
  • the-60s
    the-60s reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • the-60s
    the-60s reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • the-60s
    the-60s liked this · 3 years ago
  • oakenteapot
    oakenteapot liked this · 3 years ago
  • hands-across-the-sky
    hands-across-the-sky liked this · 3 years ago
  • mydaroga
    mydaroga reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • mydaroga
    mydaroga liked this · 3 years ago
  • sodapop182
    sodapop182 liked this · 3 years ago
  • beautifulbiscuitauthoropera
    beautifulbiscuitauthoropera reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • ahumoroussuggestion
    ahumoroussuggestion liked this · 3 years ago
  • pr6monition
    pr6monition liked this · 3 years ago
  • dumbchemist
    dumbchemist liked this · 3 years ago
  • witchy-jadda
    witchy-jadda liked this · 3 years ago
  • bambi-kinos
    bambi-kinos reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • acquiesce-song-blog
    acquiesce-song-blog liked this · 3 years ago
  • everynowandthen
    everynowandthen liked this · 3 years ago
chetthedog1904 - Untitled
Untitled

84 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags